DAKAR+ 3 REVIEW
GENDER AND EDUCATION IN KENYA SINCE WORLD EDUCATION FORUM 2000
Consultants
Paul Kiage
Woki Munyui
Pamela Wesonga
ELIMU YETU COALITION
JUNE 2003
Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS 2
LIST OF TABLES 3
ABBREVIATIONS 5
CHAPTER ONE 6
STUDY BACKGROUND 6
1.1 INTRODUCTION 6
1.1.1 Justification of the study 7
1.1.2. Study Objectives 8
1.2 METHODOLOGY 9
1.2.1 Introduction 9
1.2.2 The study population 9
1.3 RESEARCH TECHNIQUES 9
1.3.1 Tharaka District 10
1.3.2 Nairobi Informal settlements 11
1.3.3 Kajiado district 12
CHAPTER TWO 15
SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS OF GIRLS’ EDUCATION IN KENYA 15
2.1 WHY GIRLS’ EDUCATION 15
2.2 TRENDS IN GIRLS’ EDUCATION IN KENYA 16
2.3 STRATEGIES AND PLANS IN PROMOTING GIRLS EDUCATION 18
2.4 STRATEGIES BY THE KENYAN GOVERNMENT 19
CHAPTER THREE 23
CHALLENGES FACING GIRLS’ EDUCATION IN KENYA 23
3.1 INTRODUCTION 23
3.2 OUT OF SCHOOL FACTORS 23
3.4 IN- SCHOOL FACTORS 32
CHAPTER FOUR 37
INTERVENTIONS 37
4.1 INTERVENTIONS IN GIRLS EDUCATION 37
4.2 SCHOOL ESTABLISHMENT AND IMPROVEMENT 37
4.3 ADVOCACY 40
4.4 THE RE-ENTRY PROGRAMME 42
4.5 GIRL EDUCATION MOVEMENT 42
4.6 ALTERNATIVE APPROACHES TO EDUCATION 43
4.7 POVERTY REDUCTION STRATEGIES 43
4.8 SPONSORSHIPS 44
4.9 RESEARCH FINDINGS AND ACTIONS 45
4.10 LEGAL REPRESENTATION 45
4.11 SCHOOL FEEDING PROGRAMME 45
4.12 CENTERS OF EXCELLENCE 46
4.13 PARENTS INVOLVEMENT IN SCHOOL DECISIONS. 46
4.11 INTRODUCTION OF FREE PRIMARY EDUCATION (FPE) 47
4.14 NETWORKING 47
4.15 MONITORING AND EVALUATION 48
4.16 POLICIES AND PLANS TO PROMOTE GIRLS’ EDUCATION 48
4.17 ACHIEVEMENTS IN GIRLS EDUCATION 54
CHAPTER FIVE 57
BEST PRACTICES 57
5.1 CENTERS OF EXCELLENCE 57
5.2 RESCUING DOMESTIC WORKERS AND GIVING THEM AN EDUCATION 57
5.3 BRINGING SCHOOLS NEARER HOME. 58
5.4 ALTERNATIVE APPROACHES TO EDUCATION 58
5.5 ESTABLISHMENT OF BOARDING SCHOOLS 58
CHAPTER SIX 59
RECOMMENDATIONS 59
6.1 STRATEGIES THAT SHOULD BE PUT IN PLACE IN ORDER TO IMPROVE GIRLS’ EDUCATION IN KENYA 59
6.1.1 Government 59
6.1.2 Other Recommendations 63
6.1.3 Civil Society Organizations (NGOs/CSOs) and the Private sector 65
6.1.4 Other Recommendations 66
6.1.4 Community 67
6.1.6 Schools 68
6.1.7 Teachers 69
6.1.8 Parents 69
6.1.9 Pupil Recommendations 69
BIBLIOGRAPHY 70
APPENDICES 72
APPENDIX 1: ORGANIZATIONS ADDRESSING GIRLS’ EDUCATION IN KENYA 72
APPENDIX 2: MAIN AREAS OF FOCUS OF CSOS IN GENDER AND GIRLS EDUCATION 73
APPENDIX: 3: EXISTING PARTNERSHIP(S) IN GIRLS EDUCATION AMONG ORGANIZATIONS 81
APPENDIX 4: ORGANIZATIONS AND LOCATIONS OF OPERATION 83
APPENDIX 5: CASE STUDIES 85
List of Tables
TABLE 1.1: GROSS AND NET ENROLMENT BY GENDER IN PRIMARY EDUCATION PERCENT. 10
TABLE 1.2: EDUCATIONAL ASPECTS IN THE CURRENT THARAKA NITHI DISTRICT BY 2002 10
TABLE 1.3: OTHER EDUCATIONAL ASPECTS IN KAJIADO DISTRICT 13
TABLE 2.1 PRIMARY SCHOOL ENROLMENT BY STANDARD 1997-2001 (IN ‘000’) 18
TABLE 3.1: DISTRIBUTION OF FEMALE SCHOOL GOING AGE POPULATION BY REASON OF NOT BEING CURRENTLY AT SCHOOL IN PERCENTAGE. 23
TABLE 3.2: DISTRIBUTION OF HOUSEHOLD MEMBERS BY GENDER AND EDUCATION LEVEL PER CENT 25
ABBREVIATIONS
AAK Action Aid Kenya
ACK Anglican Church of Kenya
AIC Africa Inland Church
ANPCANN African Network for the Prevention and Protection
Against Abuse and Neglect
ASAL Arid and Semi Arid Lands
BEF Basic Education Fellowship
BOG Board of Governers
BTL Bible Translation and Literacy
CBOs Community Based Organizations
CCF Christian Children’s Fund
CEDAW Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women
CADEC ????
CSOs Civil Society Organizations
ECD Early Childhood Development
EFA Education for All
EYC Elimu Yetu Coalition
FAWE Forum for African Women Educationalists
FGD Focus Group Discussion
FGM Female Genital Mutilation
FPE Free Primary Education
GCN Girl Child Network
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GEM Girls’ Education Movement
GER Gross Enrolment Rate
GOK Government of Kenya
HACI Hope for African Child Initiative
HIV/AIDS Human Immuno-Deficiency Syndrome/ Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome
IGAs Income Generating Activities
IGP Income Generating Project
KAARC Kenya Alliance for the Advancement of Children
KCPE Kenya Certificate of Primary Education
KIE Kenya Institute of Education
KNUT Kenya National Union of Teachers
LWF Lutheran World Federation
MOE Ministry of Education
MOH Ministry of Health
MOU Memorandum of Understanding
NACC National Aid Control Council
NARC National Alliance Rainbow Coalition
NER Net Enrolment Rate
NGO Non Governmental Organization
NEP North Eastern Province
PTA Parents Teachers Association
STI Sexually Transmitted Infections
TSC Teachers Service Commission
UNESCO United Nations Education, Scientific and Cultural Organization
UNDP United Nations Development Programme
UNGEI United Nations Girls’ Education Initiative
UNICEF United Nations Children’s Education Fund
VSO Voluntary Service Overseas
WERK Women Educational Researchers of Kenya
CHAPTER ONE
STUDY BACKGROUND
1.1 Introduction
The World Education Forum held in April 2000 in Dakar (Senegal) reaffirmed the principles of Education for All (EFA) as initially articulated in Jomtien, Thailand, in 1990. These principles, as enunciated in the Dakar Framework for Action make special reference of the need to address gender disparities in education especially at primary level.
In this forum, the participants agreed that education is a fundamental right as enshrined in the UN declaration of Human Rights. They were alarmed by the deteriorating education situations in countries marked by large numbers of children especially girls not in school, gender and other disparities. The participants committed themselves to the attainment of the following goals on EFA; including girl’s education
1. Eliminating gender disparities in primary and secondary education by 2005, and achieving gender equality in education by 2015, with a focus on ensuring girls’ full and equal access to and achievement in basic education of good quality;
2. Ensuring that by 2015 all children, particularly girls, children in difficult circumstances and those belonging to ethnic minorities, have access to and complete free and compulsory primary education of good quality;
3. Ensuring that the learning needs of all young people and adults are met through equitable access to appropriate learning and life skills programmes;
4. Achieving a 50 per cent improvement in levels of adult literacy by 2015, especially for women, and equitable access to basic and continuing education for all adults;
5. Improving all aspects of the quality of education and ensuring excellence of all so that recognized and measurable learning outcomes are achieved by all, especially in literacy, numeracy and essential life skills.
6. Expanding and improving comprehensive early childhood care and education, especially for the most vulnerable and disadvantaged children;
To achieve these goals, the conference called upon governments, the International Community, financial and development organizations, Non Governmental and Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) to increase their support, mobilization and allocation of resources to EFA.
Kenya made major strides in education attainment in the period up to 1990 through impressive investment in schools, and public expenditure on education. As a result, primary enrolment doubled to 95 per cent. However, the 1990s have seen decline in this figure to 86.9 per cent in 1999 and 67.6 per cent in 2000 (constituting a drop of 19 percentage points in just one year). While the national Gross Enrolment Rate (GER) rose to 86.9 per cent in 1999, the recent data on Net Enrolment Rate (NER) for the 6 –13 age cohort indicate a participation level of only 67.6 per cent in 2000.
Although Kenya’s education policy does not discriminate against girls and women, significant disparities have characterized our education. There has been a serious regional disparity in primary school enrolment in Kenya, particularly in the Arid and semi Arid Lands (ASAL) where pastoralism and nomadism predominates. In North Eastern for example, the average primary school NER is about 20.5 per cent. By gender, the figures are 25.8 per cent for boys and 14.6 per cent for girls. In general, completion rates indicate that slightly more boys than girls complete primary education.
The NARC government declared Free Primary Education (FPE) beginning January 2003. This was in recognition of the importance of education as a human right as per the provisions of the Children’s Act (2001). However, this process has been severely hampered by constraints that prevent the girl-child specifically from going to school. Available research shows that gender disparities in enrolment and completion of primary education in Kenya is prevalent especially in poor urban, rural and arid and semi-arid areas and that the causes are multifaceted; driven by the national economic environment, the community, the household and the school environment. This study aimed at finding out if there is any progress/efforts made towards improvement of girls’ education.
1.1.1 Justification of the study
Recent social science literature has established the link between gender, education and development. Research shows a positive correlation between even a minimum amount of education and the development of a nation. The education of women and girls which has been demonstrated as having multiplier effects is particularly beneficial not only from the point of view of the individual and the household, but for the society as a whole. In fact, the social returns of female education are high and exceed those of male education (Choski, 1994; Summers, 1992; Herz et al, 1992; King and Hill, 1991)
Female education empowers women to bring about other necessary changes and helps to break through the vicious cycle of poverty and deprivation. (Summers, 1992:11) Thus urges summers “Once all the benefits are recognized, investment in the education of girls may be well the highest return investment available in the developing world”. King and Hill (1991) go even further to caution that “failure to raise women’s education to equality with men’s impacts negatively on productivity, income and quality of life”.
Most studies done on girls’ education have focused on challenges facing their education but none has been done to indicate the progress made in girls’ education since the world education forum in Dakar. Still less has been done to show comparative studies of different locations in Kenya. This current study is pioneering in those areas.
It is against this backdrop that Elimu Yetu Coalition, commissioned a study to assess the progress Kenya has made since Dakar 2000 in girls’ education with particular focus to primary education and more so girls from the marginalized communities and disadvantaged backgrounds. This assessment was conducted to provide information to the Elimu Yetu Coalition for use in its campaigns and advocacy work. The government, policy makers and other actors can also use the findings to promote girls’ education
1.1.2. Study Objectives
1. Assess the progress Kenya has made since Dakar 2000 in girls’ education with particular focus on primary education.
2. Identify problems/challenges facing girls’ education in Kenya more particularly girls from marginal communities, hardship areas and disadvantaged families/backgrounds.
3. Gather information to inform EYC campaigns and other advocacy work
4. Conduct an assessment of existing/ on going efforts around girls’ education; who is doing what and how and where? What has worked and what has not worked.
5. Document some of the best practices in girls’ education and make proposals on strategies Kenya needs to put in place to achieve gender parity by 2005.
1.2 Methodology
1.2.1 Introduction
The study used a variety of qualitative research approaches to generate data from relevant respondents who are stakeholders in the education sector from three districts namely Nairobi, Tharaka and Kajiado. The study areas are characterized by different socio-cultural, economic, and environmental problems.
1.2.2 The study population
The target population for the study were parents, teachers, community leaders/members, education officials, and children in and out of school, Civil Society Organizations, research organizations, among others.
1. 2.3 Research Techniques
Qualitative information on statistical data was collected from secondary sources; policy documents and research reports. The qualitative primary data were generated through participatory research and questionnaires as shown below:
In-depth Interviews: Informal interviews were held with key informants who included education officials, civil society organizations, community leaders, head teachers and pupils.
Case studies: The case study method focused on documenting voices of children out of school and newly enrolled FPE beneficiaries.
Focus Group Discussions: (FGDs) were held with parents and community members/leaders in each of the study districts. FGDs were also held with homogeneous gender specific of 6-8 pupils grouped into different categories of girls and boys. FGD interview guides were used to facilitate the discussions.
Literature review of policy documents and research reports by CSOs, the government and research institutes.
Data Analysis: Data was analyzed according to the study objectives and expected outputs and disintegrated in terms of gender, region, year, urban/rural, and pastoralists. Case studies have been presented in narrative form to document voices and experiences of girls. Different analytical tools have also been used to present specific findings.
Reporting: The report has a total of six chapters. Some information is also appended at the end of the report. These include the ToR, Organizations and locations of operation, and review instruments and case studies
1.4 Context of the study
The study was conducted in three districts namely; Kajiado, Tharaka and Nairobi. In Nairobi, the study covered the informal settlements mainly Kibera, Kariobangi and Mukuru. The table below shows the gross enrolment and Net enrolment rates by gender in primary schools in the three districts.
TABLE 1.1: GROSS AND NET ENROLMENT BY GENDER IN PRIMARY EDUCATION PERCENT.
DistrictMaleFemaleGross EnrolmentNet EnrolmentGross EnrolmentNet EnrolmentNairobi90.576.595.882.7Tharaka85.675.1101.881.1Kajiado80.762.861.454.7Source: Compiled from GoK, 2000
1.3.1 Tharaka District
The current Tharaka district was curved out of the former Tharaka Nithi district in 1998. As such, its education performance given in 2002 is based on the former Tharaka Nithi district. In the plan period 1997-2001, there was improved enrolment in schools. Of major concern in Tharaka district is the high drop-out rate in primary schools which stands at 32.79 per cent and 47.75 per cent for boys and girls respectively. This is attributed to poverty, which stands at 65 per cent in absolute terms. Cultural beliefs particularly the female genital mutilation (FGM) practice largely contributes to the high drop out rate among girls. The distribution of relief food and the school-feeding programme in the district are some of the indications of the extent of poverty. In the year 2000 alone, 30,000 school going children benefited from the school feeding programme and 42,500 people received relief food. This translates to about 69per cent of the population.
The practice of FGM is very high in the district inspite of a lot of efforts made by the provincial administration to stop it. The prevalence of HIV/Aids is estimated at 25 per cent. The district also faces shortage of teachers and early marriages are common. NGOs are expected to actively participate in educational development. NGO’s that operate in the district include Plan International, Bible Translation and Literacy (BTL), Catholic Diocese of Meru, Christian Children’s Fund and Save the Children Canada. Tables 1.2 shows educational aspects in the district
TABLE 1.2: EDUCATIONAL ASPECTS IN THE CURRENT THARAKA DISTRICT BY 2002
Aspect Number, per cent, ratio Primary schools 152Boys enrolment in primary schools 12114 (93.5per cent)Girls enrolment in primary schools 12840 (99.5per cent)Boys drop-out rate in primary schools 32.79per centGirls drip-out rate in primary school 47.75per centPrimary school teacher/ pupil ratio1.55Literacy level (males)84.7per centLiteracy level (females)69.6per cent Source: GoK, 2002
1.3.2 Nairobi Informal settlements
Urban population in Kenya accounts for 35 per cent of the country’s total population. Over 31 percent of the urban populations live in unplanned informal settlements of many urban centres across the country. 25 percent of these live in Nairobi where 55 percent live in informal settlements that cover only 5 percent of the total land.
Kibera Informal Settlements
Kibera informal settlement is the third largest in Africa and the largest in Kenya. The slum lies on 250 hectres and is composed of nine villages:
a) Silanga
b) Lindi
c) Kambi muuru
d) Kisumu Ndogo
e) Kianda
f) Mashimoni
g) Gatwikira
h) Laini Saba
i) Soweto, and
j) Makina.
Kibera slum is home of 528,000 people and has a population density of 250 household units. Average household is six persons.
Literacy levels in kibera are generally low but residents have a positive perception of education as a light of development, a gate of escaping out of poverty and a basic determinant of the quality of life.
School enrolment in Kibera fell from 89 per cent in 1970 to a mere 37 percent in 2000. Although the government has introduced free primary education, Kibera residents are not benefiting. There are only five public schools located around the formal estates in Kibera. These schools mostly admit pupils from the estates and very few from the slum. They are also far from the slum dwellers especially for the young children who may not be able to walk for long distances.
Inside the slum, there are no public schools. Communities, individuals and religious organisations have established private schools. NGOs like Oxfam have come up to assist these schools and lobbied for communities and parents involvement in the management of these schools. Oxfam is working in four schools in Kibera located within the four villages they operate in. In order to provide education to the community, Oxfam has assisted the four schools by renovating and constructing classrooms. Pupils in these schools pay Kshs. 50 a month, which amounts to Kshs 150 a term. This money is not used in the running of the school but is kept in a bank account for future use when Oxfam pulls out. It also provides teaching and learning material for teachers and pupils. It also pays honoraria for the teachers in these schools. The pupils are allowed to go to school without uniforms but those who afford do buy.
In private schools, pupils pay an average of Kshs. 500 a month, which amounts to Kshs. 1500 a term. Some of the needy pupils in these schools are sponsored by religious organizations like Christ the king Catholic Church, Calvary Church and ACK. .
Kariobangi is located in the eastern side of Nairobi city. It is a relatively better living area than Kibera. Most of the pupils have access to existing public schools. On the introduction of FPE, enrolment in this area rose by over 30 percent
1.3.3 Kajiado district
The district is one of the seventeen districts in the Rift Valley Province. It covers an area of 21,105 Km2. It is divided into six administrative divisions namely ; Central, Magadi, Loitoktok, Mashuru, Namanga and Ngong. The general topography of the district is characterized by plains and volcanic hills. The plains are dissected by several valleys. Children have to walk up and down the ridges in order to access schools.
The total population of the district by 2001 projection was 502,861. The annual population growth rate of the district is estimated to be 5.54 per cent per annum. The high population growth has strained the provision of essential facilities such as schools. The age group 6-13 years (primary) numbered 114533 in 2001. This calls for increase of schools to accommodate the growing number.
The district is faced with severe shortage of surface water due to the fact that most river and streams in the district are seasonal. During the rainy season, children miss school due to flooding of rivers. There is frequent drought experienced in nearly all the parts of the district. Consequently, families are always on the move with their animals in search of pastures.
The district also has absolute poverty at 15.28 per cent and this also contributes to high rate of school drop-out. These drop-outs then result to child labour to supplement family income (GoK, 1997 and 2002).
During the 1997-2001 plan period, the number of primary schools in the district increased and this encouraged more enrolment and reduced the distance from one school to the other. More trained teachers were also deployed in the district. Until recently, young girls were forced into early marriage and thus denied access to education. Lack of education for girls meant that poverty would be a constant threat in their lives. However, NGOs and the government have intervened to empower women. Lobby groups have also been formed to campaign for the girl child’s education. Educated women are expected to become change agents against the negative attitude towards girl child education (GoK, 2002). According to GoK (1997), the number of schools in the district were few and under –utilized. They were widely scattered and the pupils had to walk long distances to reach the nearest school. There was also scarcity of teachers in most schools. The worst problem was that of low enrolment and constant absenteeism by pupils due to early marriages, moranism and long distances to school which are at times unsafe for the young children. The cultural beliefs amongst the maasais who are the dominant ethnic group in the district has affected children’s education. Early marriages for instance have greatly contributed to low literacy levels for the girl child. After the initiation ceremony, most of the new initiates (morans) do not go back to school since they are assigned responsibility of herding the livestock.
In the 2002-2008 plan period the government plans to expand education facilities and increase awareness on the importance of education for girls and boys to improve enrolment and retention rates of students in schools. The government recognizes that the main constraints are low priority of education due to pastoralism way of life, which encourages high mobility, and child labour. Other constraints include low enrolment and retention of students in schools, disruption of schools due to frequent drought and famine, understaffing of primary schools, low attendance due to long distances from and to school. Thus, it is the governments plan to sensitize parents through identified role models on the importance of formal education for their own children. The government shall also encourage and strengthen lobby groups in their role of ensuring that the girl child secures her education. Indeed, these groups have been effective in stepping down early marriages for the girl child through counseling the school going girls and taking up cases of early marriages with the administration. They also look for bursaries to assist the needy students.
It is important to note that most primary schools in the district are under-utilized due to low enrolment particularly in Magadi division and lack of educational facilities such a teaching and learning materials. By 2002, Kajiado district had 198 primary schools (GoK, 2002). The table below shows the trend in primary education in Kajiado district.
TABLE 1.3: OTHER EDUCATIONAL ASPECTS IN KAJIADO DISTRICT
Aspect Number, per cent, ratio Male enrolment in primary schools 29431 (55.8per cent) against a national figure of 494,400Female enrolment in primary schools 24847 (50per cent) against a national figure of 471,500Male drop out rate in primary schools 8.5per centFemale drop-out rate in primary schools 6.27per centPrimary teacher/pupil ratio1:41Average years of male primary school attendance 7Average years of female primary school attendance 6Literacy levels (males)66.87per centLiteracy levels (females) 49.03per cent Source: GoK, 2002
CHAPTER TWO
SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS OF GIRLS’ EDUCATION IN KENYA
2.1 Why girls’ education
Studies worldwide have revealed the depressed status of women and girls in relation to men and boys (Reuter, 1975; Schlegel’ 1977; Rapanex, 1973). Right from her inception, the female suffers various forms of discrimination:
“Customs, laws and social practices frequently
make the girl child the lesser child” (UNICEF, 1990)
Females in poverty experience a double disadvantage. They bear the major brunt of poverty worldwide (UNDP, 1990; World bank, 1990). Research findings reveal that “poor women have seen little or no progress in the last two decades in their living conditions, incomes or development resources, particularly credit, training and technology” (UNICEF 1990). Some of the disadvantages suffered by the female by virtue of her gender are:
Female children in developing countries get less food, health care and education than male children
The female illiteracy rate for the developing world is two thirds that of the male
The risk of death for an expectant mother in developing countries is 50 times that in industrialized countries
Much of the work that girls and women do remains “invisible” not revealed in national accounting and censuses. Women work 25 per cent more than men and much of their work…household work and growing subsistence crops…is unpaid
Adult women get less education, less professional training and lower pay for even longer hours worked than men.
Girls and women encounter cultural, social, legal and economic obstacles that even poor boys and men do not. (UNICEF, 1990)
Some of the positive implications of female education include:
The improvement of children’s health through increased economic resources available to the household. It can be argued that educated women can access employment more easily than the uneducated. They are also more knowledgeable on income generating activities. Their earnings add more value to the quality of life of their families. Not only are they able to provide healthy food for their families but also medical care and other necessities.
An influence on the household spending preferences in favour of food consumed by children
A greater willingness to invest in all children, particularly girls. An educated woman wants the same for her daughters and will therefore take both her sons and daughters to school.
The reduction of family size by differing marriage, lowering fertility rates, increasing the practice of contraceptive use and opting to have fewer children when married. Educated women will plan their families in relation to their ability to provide for them. They will also space their children and therefore suffer no birth related problems as a result of frequent pregnancies.
A large increase in wage earnings for themselves and their families.
Ability to access information and use it to better their lives for example to understand and protect their rights.
In order to achieve Education for All (EFA), we must ensure that the most disadvantaged are able to access their right to education. Basic data, even in its crudest form shows that the largest single group of such disadvantaged children is girls….. Of the approximately 145 million children between the ages 6-11years, two thirds are female.
Gender issues in education and indeed in society affect both boys and girls. Often, girls fail to reap the intended benefits of development activities. However, when education systems are made gender sensitive through a focus on their impact on girls, boys also benefit whereas the reverse is not necessarily true.
It is thus crucial that policies and laws are put in place that will support the participation of females in the education system of a country. The education provided should however be an empowering one.
2.2 Economic Trends and Girls’ Education in Kenya
In the last three decades Kenya’s socio-economic development has not been consistent. In the first twenty years, it displayed rapid expansion of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) at an average of 7 per cent when the population growth stood at 3.5 – 4.0 per cent. The positive outcome of this expansion included:
Sustained increase in the per capita income of the people;
Improved access to health care and consequently decline in infant mortality and increase in the average lifespan;
Increased access to education as attested by primary school gross enrolment ratio (GER) of 95 per cent per cent by 1986.
The momentum however has not persisted due to a variety of factors. Over the last 15 years, the per capita income has declined, unemployment has more than doubled in urban areas and landlessness in rural areas has increased. In addition, infant and child mortality rates have stagnated in the late 1980s and early 1990s. There are indications that child malnutrition may actually have grown.
Exogenous factors such as repeated droughts, continued high cost of oil and the global recession no doubt has contributed to the sluggish growth of the Kenyan economy since the 1980s. The rising incidence of HIV/AIDS has also been identified as a factor affecting the country’s economy. However, lack of commitment and accountability particularly within the public sector also cannot be overruled as having been instrumental in bringing about this situation.
Since the 1997/1998 fiscal year, the total expenditure in education has been on the increase. The budget estimates for the fiscal year 2001/2002 rose by 13.3 per cent to stand at 56,295.8 million from 49,694.0 in 2000/2001.
Under recurrent general administration and planning expenditure which includes salaries and related items constituted 83.0 per cent of the total. Budget estimates for primary education declined by 9.1 per cent from Kshs. 816.2 million in 2000/2001 to Kshs. 742.0 million in 2001/2002.
Primary school gross enrolment rose by 4.2 per cent to 6,314,600 in 2001from 6,155,500 in 2000. This constitutes 91.2 per cent of the primary school going age population. Further analysis reveal that standard 1 constituted 15.3 per cent of the pupil population, declining to 13.7 per cent in standard 4 and 8.0 per cent in standard 8. This is mainly attributed to a progressively higher drop- out rate between the classes. In 2001, primary schools enrolled a total of 6,065,505 pupils accounting for 96.1 per cent of the total primary schools’ enrolment.
Gender balance in education indicates that girls constituted 49.3 per cent in 2001 reflecting a slight decline from 49.4 per cent recorded in 2000. The distribution of girls in standard 1-5 and 8 is lower than boys while the converse is true for 6 and 7. In 2001, a total of 514,350 candidates sat for the KCPE and of these, 47.5 per cent were girls.
Table 2.1 below shows primary school enrolment by gender and standard for the period 1997-2001.
TABLE 2.1 PRIMARY SCHOOL ENROLMENT BY STANDARD 1997-2001 (IN ‘000’)
std1997199719981998199919992000200020012001BoyGirlBoyGirlBoyGirlBoyGirlsBoysGirls1498.2468.2503.1473509.9477519.1505.1499.4471.52442.9421.1460.4431.1462.3434.8482.8477.7475.24513402.1370.4428.2405.8438.5415.2437.6391.1451.2429.94379.5372.4397.1390.3418.5403.6415.9420.3439.8427.55331.7334.6351.3352.3362.1364.5358.9368.9392388.26304.1312.4316.2326333.6337.2339.9347.6351.1355.67301.2310.9317.2331.3310.6321.7330.4334.7329.6341.98220.5207.1221215.3246.6228243232.6262.4248.3TOTAL2880.22797.12994.52925.13082.22982.13117.63037.93200.73113.8Grand
Total5677.35919.66064.36155.56314.6Source:
2.4 Strategies by the Kenyan government
Educational policies in Kenya are based on the philosophy spelt out in sessional paper number 10 of 1965 of African socialism and its application to planning in Kenya. This was and remains the definitive statement of national philosophy and the development blue print for all sectors of socio-economic and political life. The paper emphasizes the importance of education. Since independence the Kenyan government has consistently pursued policies aimed at expanding and strengthening basic education programmes (Republic of Kenya, 1992).
These policies are evident in the reports made by commissions formed to look into the education system of the country. The Ominde report (1964) the first commission set up immediately after independence and all other education reports such as Gachathi report (1976), Mackay report (1981), Kamunge report (1988) and the master plan on education and training all made reference to the need for accelerating the education for girls.
The Koech report recognizes the tremendous efforts made by the government to improve girls’ education, including affirmative action in the expansion of facilities to enable girls to study science and technical subjects and a policy to allow girls who drop out due to pregnancy to continue with education. These and other factors have yielded benefits shown by increase of girls’ participation in schooling (Republic of Kenya, 1999).
Kenya can be said to be committed to redressing factors affecting girls’ education as evidenced by her participation in international forums on gender and girls’ education. She has been a signatory to most conventions in education and has ratified several international instruments that impact on the gender thus joining the global community committed to redressing imbalances related to gender learning and underdevelopment. The Kenya government alongside other member of the international community committed themselves to specific intentions of improving the living conditions and the education of children. These include:
Convention on the elimination of all form of discrimination against women (CEDAW, 1979)
World Conference on Education For All, Jomtiem (1990)
Cairo Conference on Population (1994) which highlights the link between education and demography, emphasizing the need to ensure equality of women and men in the private sectors especially with regard to access to education.
UN Standard Rule on Equalization Opportunities for Persons with Disabilities
Beijing Conference on Women (1995) which promoted and stressed the full participation of women in all aspects of society and emphasized the need to guarantee access to education and learning opportunities for women and the girl child.
Social Summit in Copenhagen (1995) which identified education and learning as critical factors to overcoming poverty and social and economic marginalization of women
Kampala Declaration of Empowerment of Women through functional literacy and education for the girl child (1996)
Dakar World Conference on Education For All 2000
Progress has been made towards domestication of these instruments but gaps as detailed in the next chapter still remain and need to be addressed. The current study reviewed the progress made since Dakar world conference on education for all with specific emphasis to girls’ primary education.
CHAPTER THREE
CHALLENGES FACING GIRLS’ EDUCATION IN KENYA
3.1 Introduction
This section examines the barriers affecting girls’ education from literature reviewed and from the point of view of CSOs working towards the promotion of girls’ education, government officials, parents, community leaders and pupils.
The table below shows the distribution of female school going age population and the reason for not being in school in percentage figures. It should be noted that 5.9 percent did not indicate reasons for being out of school.
TABLE 3.1: DISTRIBUTION OF FEMALE SCHOOL GOING AGE POPULATION BY REASON OF NOT BEING CURRENTLY AT SCHOOL IN PERCENTAGE.
DistrictToo oldGot marriedToo farCannot affordGot employedBecame an apprenticeWork at homeSchool not entire stingCultural ritualsIllnessPregnancyFailed examsOtherNot statedNBI1.924.81.334.45.20.901.7004.75.713.65.9Tharaka 71.33.8018.1000001.805.200Kajiado2.225.2021.403.8021.82.37.711.911.900Source: Compiled from GoK, 2000
Problems affecting girls’ education can be categorized into two broad areas namely: I. Out of school factors, II. In-school factors. These two broad categories are not mutually exclusive but are interrelated.
3.2 Out of school factors
Early / Forced marriages
Early marriages are mainly motivated by the desire for dowry on the part of the girls’ parents. This practice is common in Kuria and Kajiado districts where it is normal for under age girls of less than 15 years of age to be married off to older men.
Among the Kuria, this practice is aggravated by a traditional practice called “Nyumba Mboke” which permits a woman, usually old ones, to marry another woman, mostly young girls. It was commonly practiced when a woman was either barren or has lost a son who had not married. She then marries a woman who is allowed to cohabit with any man of her choice and the resultant offsprings are seen to be sustaining the son’s name. Besides interference with their education, such young wives who have no permanent husbands are highly exposed to the risk of Aids and other sexually transmitted diseases.
In Kajiado, girls as young as 12 years are arranged for marriage and forced into it. In Tharaka and Nairobi informal settlements, the study found that girls who drop out because of pregnancy choose to get married. Some also seek refuge in marriage after losing their parents.
Female circumcision (FC) or Female Genital Mutilation (FGM)
FGM amongst girls leads to loss of interest in school afterwards since the girls are then classified as adult women who should be married. These girls begin to behave ‘like adults’ and often engage in sexual activities at will. Ensuing pregnancies and cases of HIV/AIDS leads to school drop out. Also medical complications arising out of the practice causes dropouts among girls in some communities. Female circumcision is an old traditional practice, which is highly respected among the Meru, Maasai, Kisii and Kuria communities; just to mention a few.
It is commonly accepted that once a girl has undergone the cut she is then ready for marriage, and more often than not, what usually follows the circumcision season is a number of marriages. The unfortunate reality is that the age at which this exercise is undertaken has been decreasing; a fact that has continued interfering with more and more school going children. The practice is so entrenched in some areas that even daughters of parents who are opposed to it, probably due to peer influence, sneak and present themselves to the circumcisers.
The enrolment of girls in primary schools in Marakwet district rose by more than 30 per cent in two years when the girls were offered an alternative rite of passage. This case highlights the close but often ignored association between enrolment and FGM.
Parents’ Negative Attitude towards Girls’ Education
In the three ditricts, i.e. Tharaka, Kajiado and Nairobi both parents and members of the communities’ were said to view education of girls as of no importance. Some parents believe that educating a girl is like enriching her husband’s family and educating a boy is enriching their own family. One respondent described the argument of parents thus: “Parents argue that educating a girl has no benefit since it’s like watering your neighbour’s shamba”(Key Informant: GCN, Nairobi)
This factor was more pronounced in Kajiado district where girls are married off even to old men in order to fetch dowry. In Nairobi, though it may not seem so pronounced, pupils interviewed felt that girls education was not valued as much as boys. Parents on the other hand insisted that they valued education for their sons and daughters equally.
In Nairobi, boys felt that girls education was not as valued as theirs thus the need to keep a girl at home and send the boy to school when need arises. Parents were quoted to have said that educated girls forgot their parents after getting good jobs; hence there is no need of educating them.
Most Kenyan traditions continue to encourage preferential treatment of boys. Boys are regarded as assets and are treated as such, usually to the detriment of the girls. Where there are inadequate resources families prioritize the education of boys rather than girls. Many parents do not value education for girls and as a result not all girls of school going age are enrolled in school. This situation weighs against girls in two ways:
Firstly, the girls are yours only before marriage hence the reluctance to spend so much on them on behalf of your future in-laws.
Secondly, the girls are usually married off and the cows paid as bride price are then used to educate the boys. In this sense they are used as a source of finance for the boy’s education; a practice that further worsens the already existing gender imbalance in education.
Some people even believe that ‘too much’ education may prevent a girl from getting a suitable husband and that educated girls may cause difficulties in marriage and lead to divorce. These perceptions often lead to many girls being undereducated. As such, fewer women pursue higher education as indicated in the table below.
TABLE 3.2: DISTRIBUTION OF HOUSEHOLD MEMBERS BY GENDER AND EDUCATION LEVEL PER CENT
District
Male FemaleNone Primary Secondary Higher None Primary SecondaryHigher Nairobi 5.846.535.811.99.458.627.54.6Tharaka Nithi 15.965.918.4021.264.214.70Kajiado 37.852.39.10.954.238.17.40.35
Source: Compiled from: GoK, 2000
Gender division of labour in the household The work burden of girls at home was repeatedly cited as a factor negatively affecting their education. Domestic chores for girls are very many and demanding hence girls have no time to study. In a study on Refugee Girls’ Education, a girl was quoted thus: “In the morning I make porridge to feed mother and father. After that, I come to school. I leave home at 7.30 am and reach school at 8.00 a.m. I am in school up to 12.00 noon and then return home. Then I grind the cereals (sorghum and maize mixed with wheat from the ration) for one hour. Then I clean the tukul and go to fetch water from the river. The river is near my home so it takes me only five minutes. I fetch 20 liters of water three times a day. I start working for the family again after this. We eat sorghum (maa) with vegetable or okra. If we get the ration, then the parents may buy meat. At 4.00 p.m we start grinding again. Between 5.00-6.00 p.m I am busy in the process of cooking. After this I try to wash the plates and put them in place”(Wamahiu. S, 2002)
Although the quotation above depicts the life of a refugee girl in Uganda, it has no much difference with the situation of girls in Kenya. Key informants described similar duties for Kenyan girls. For instance, one informant said, if there is a baby to be taken care of, it will be the girl to do so at the expense of her education. Parents keep children at home on market days. A key informant from the Aga khan Foundation was quoted saying;
“Some parents force their daughters to carry their siblings to school. At first
teachers discouraged them but realized that this increased the girls’ dropout rates, they allowed them” (Key Informant: Aga Khan Foundation Nairobi).
In Nairobi informal settlements, both boys and girls who were interviewed reported that girls were overburdened with housework which included cooking, cleaning, washing and taking care of the young ones. One boy was quoted thus:
My sister is my mother’s assistant. She even takes the baby to hospital. She also goes looking for water where she at times queue the whole day. Pupil, Shadrack Kimalel School, Kibera, Nairobi.
On the other hand, parents in Nairobi felt that girls were not distracted from studying by the chores at home but were influenced by the video shows in the neighbourhood, which they watched in the evenings.
Children in paid work In most Kenyan communities, societal attitude towards boys work is to earn an income. The problem of child labour exclusively came out from an interview with BEF, which works in Mbeere an area engaged in miraa business. Children, both boys and girls work in these farms. In Nairobi, girls are engaged in housework. Most of these girls are from the informal settlements aged between 6 and 18 years old. In Kibera where children are still in the private and community schools in the informal settlements, boys engage in hawking wares during the weekends in order to earn money for fees. They also seek casual labour during the holidays. Girls on the other hand work in saloons. Some give in to sex in exchange for money. In Kajiado, boys abandon schooling to become morans . They move from home to live in the forests and feed on stolen cows. In some cases, they also abduct girls. Some boys however are withdrawn from school by their parents against their wish in order to graze.
HIV/AIDS
In most countries Kenya included, HIV/AIDS is the most urgent danger facing young people. Girls and young women are most vulnerable and have the highest rates of infections. The economic vulnerability of girls puts pressure on them to exchange sex for money and makes it difficult for them to negotiate safer sex. Culturally girls are brought up to feel subservient to boys and men. Many girls lack the self-confidence or social skills to resist sexual harassment or exploitation.
The consequences of early, unprotected sexual activity among young Kenyans are no longer limited to millions of episodes of STDs and hundreds of thousands of unwanted pregnancies and induced abortions every year among teenage girls of school going age. In addition to these threats to their health, well-being and survival, Kenya’s young girls now have to face up reality of HIV/AIDS in their daily lives. Studies done in Kenya and elsewhere shows that levels of HIV infection are alarmingly high among young people, particularly young girls. In regions/provinces where HIV is common, greater sexual activity during early teens translates inexorably into a high prevalence of HIV among girls. The National AIDS Programme – Kenya and Population Council (1999) study in Kisumu established high HIV prevalence among girls aged 15-19 as shown in the figure below.
Figure 1 HIV Prevalence rates among teenagers in Kisumu
Source: National AIDS Programme and Population Council (1999)
One of the worst consequences of AIDS deaths is an increase in the number of orphans. It is commonly assumed that children drop out of school when their parents die, whether of AIDS or another cause. While there has been little research on HIV AIDS and Education, a few studies in Kenya point to AIDS in the family as the direct cause of school dropout. Currently the number of HIV/AIDS orphans stands at about 900,000 and is projected to increase to 1.5 million by 2005 (MoH/NACC 2002). In the study conducted by Population Communication Africa (Tony Johnstone, 1999) among orphans in the Rusinga Island of Suba District, the study found that boys tended to give economic reasons for dropping out of primary school (64 per cent said they could not afford school fees or needed to earn cash from fishing) while 28 per cent of girls said that they had become pregnant and 41per cent had left to get married.
Up to 200,000 children under the age of 5 years have been infected by AIDS. AIDS has orphaned over a million children. These children are left bereft of protection and parental guidance as well as basic needs. Often the girls are forced to leave school and begin to act as mothers to their siblings, and to head households (the number of child-headed households in Kenya now stands at about 5 per cent. In addition, lack of medicare and social stigma impacts negatively on these children as other children/teachers are reluctant to interact with them. The loss of teachers through death: 1,800 per annum, largely attributable to AIDS, reinforce inequitable variations in pupil to teacher ratios – usually girls are the first casualties in such eventualities. One of the more unfortunate effects is that a number of school going girls are infected by AIDS often as a result of forced sex with male teachers or through rapes while enroute to school.
In Nairobi informal settlements, the impact of HIV AIDS has been great. Child headed families are on the increase. Girls have taken the extra burden of looking after their siblings. Some have sought employment as maids in order to earn a living while some have been forced into prostitution. However, in Kajiado and Tharaka, HIV /AIDS cases are minimal. In Kajiado, a few girls were said to have dropped out after their parents’ deaths. An interesting finding was that in the Coast Region where the Aga Khan foundation is working, parents who are infected and sickly force their daughters to carry their siblings to school or forfeit their schooling. Initially teachers discouraged this as it caused a lot of interruptions. The result was increase in the drop out rate of girls. The teachers have reverted their decision and they now allow girls to go with their siblings to school. Poverty and Child Prostitution National poverty level in Kenya currently stands at 56 percent. 74 percent of the people living below poverty line are from the N.E province. Marginal and urban poor areas in Kenya are characterized by hardship and mostly poverty. Poverty combined with the traditional practice of preference for boys influences parents to take sons to school rather than their daughters in situations of economic constraints. When a community is faced with such high poverty level girls’ education is compromised.
Research conducted in various parts of Africa, Kenya included, indicate that girls’ access and persistence in school tend to be more affected than that of boys in times of economic difficulties. Parents opt not to send their daughters to school or withdraw them prematurely because of the higher opportunity costs: Girls labour is sometimes seen to be imperative for family survival, as when the mother is sick, or out earning an income. Even when the imperativeness is absent, girls are still expected to provide unpaid family labour, more so than boys.
In Mukuru, Nairobi girls engaged in prostitution in order to meet their needs
The other problem is girls’ engagements in prostitution due to poverty. This being an industrial area, there are many young men who lure girls to their houses by enticing them with money (Key Informant:: St Elizabeth Mukuru Nairobi).
Prostitution or child sex workers are practiced so that they can earn for their family the “next meal”. In Kibera, single mothers were said to be sending their children to earn meals through prostitution. In Kariobangi, girls drop out of school to work as maids. In Kajiado, the situation is not any different. Those who cannot afford to stay in school drop out to get married. Most girls who were interviewed lacked money to buy sanitary wear. They stayed away from school during their menstrual periods. In Tharaka, the poverty level was said to be so high such that girls were engaging in prostitution to meet their needs. This was said to be most common in the area near the district headquarters where there is always a large number of visitors. Policemen and drivers visiting the headquarters take advantage of the girls.
Poverty also means a poorer learning environment at home. In Kajido, girls reported having no space to do their homework. In cases where there were visitors, the girls lacked space even to sleep. In the urban settlements in Nairobi, most families live in one-roomed houses. The children have no space to study. Safety and security factors
Long distances to schools from home expose girls to physical and sexual dangers. In urban areas like Nairobi, public transport pose particular dangers to girls commuting to and from schools (Chege et al, 1994).
Girls walking long distances to school are affected in some regions leading to drop out. Inadequate security in areas like Baragoi (Samburu) and other remote areas (50per cent of pupils in Kerio Valley have recently been displaced from school, due to cattle rustling, according to the Kenya National Union of Teachers (KNUT). Cattle rustling between the Maasai, Kuria and the Pokot is widespread and provides dowry for young girls whose parents cannot resist the temptation of a good herd of cattle. Additionally, with the many cows in the homestead, the family feels insecure since cattle rustlers can attack them any time.
Distance to School
In this study, the informants repeatedly cited the distance between schools and the homes as a factor affecting girls’ education. In Kajiado, the luckiest girl is said to walk about 16 kilometers to school, while those in the interior of Kajiado cover an approximate distance of 40 kilometers. Long distance to schools in these regions is caused by pastoralist practices that lead to communities shifting. Parents in Kajiado used long distance to school as an excuse to keep their girls at home. They also fear that their daughters might be raped on their way to school. In Tharaka, children have to cover long distances to reach school.
Teenage Pregnancy
According to the Kenya Domestic Household Survey, adolescent mothers constitute more than half (55 per cent) of the adolescent girls. Most of these girls drop out of schools due to stigmatization. A recent FAWE study revealed the following as the main reasons why girls get pregnant at school age:
Inappropriate socialization towards submission to boys and men.
Lack of correct sexual information that would help them to deter sexual activity.
Inexistence of contemporary sex education, either within the family, community or in school.
Lack of dialogue between parents and their children, both boys and girls.
Lack of knowledge of, and access to, preventive methods
Existence of policy barriers to some preventive methods by unmarried girls.
Glorification of sexual experiences among boys resulting in irresponsible sex and impregnation of girls.
Sugar daddy syndrome.
Sexual abuse by teachers and other adults.
Defilement and rape.
Although the Kenyan government has a policy allowing re-entry of girls to schools after giving birth this is still a challenge to girls’ education since they suffer from stigmatization, ridicule and abuse from both teachers and other pupils. With the birth of the baby, girl’s responsibilities increase. Lack of a nanny to take care of the baby keeps girls at home. In most cases both girls and parents are not aware of the re-entry policy, which has not been disseminated in schools and communities. Most believe that girls cannot go back to school upon giving birth.
In Tharaka, girls who became pregnant were said to be performing abortion secretly thus endangering their lives.
Environment and Natural factors Bad peers, movies and bars near schools and homes especially in Urban areas (Mombasa, Kariobangi, Mukuru and Nairobi) were said to affect girls’ education. Pornographic movies in the neighborhood exposed girls to immorality. Drunkenness and drug abuse are daily activities in these areas. Girls are exposed to such hostile environment on their way to and from school. In Kibera, drugs and packaged beer is sold in the kiosks. Drunkards use these to lure girls into sex.
In Tharaka and Kajiado, distance between schools and home is far. Children have to cross seasonal rivers to reach school. During the rainy season, these rivers flood and are dangerous to cross. Both boys and girls have to stay at home until the rivers become passable. In the same region, presence of wild animals is a hindrance to education. In one instance, an elephant was said to have kept children from going to school due to fear of attack.
3.4 In- school factors
These are hindrances that arise from and are part of the school environment.
Harassment by boys and teachers It was reported that teachers and boys harass girls in schools. Teachers seek sexual favors from girls consequently impregnating them. In a school in Kibera, boys were said to compete with teachers for girls. In cases where a teacher and a boy were interested in the same girl, the teacher picked on the boy and punished him without offence. Teachers were also said to use girls to run errands like fetching water and cooking for them. The female teacher factor
Lack of female teachers as role models to girls affects girls’ education. In Tharaka, a semi arid district, female teachers are rare. Girls expressed the need for female teachers in schools so that they could confide in them and emulate them. Most girls refused to discuss their problems with male teachers in the absence of female teachers.
Among the Muslim communities, lack of single-sex schools may constitute a barrier to female education. Even in non-Muslim communities, parents worry about the sexual safety of their daughters where male teachers predominate, as they do in remote areas of the country. Female teachers tend to cluster into urban areas.
A key informant from Oxfam explained that girls who go to school in the marginal areas are given scholarships for further studies, after which they get good jobs and rarely do they go back home to teach or work there, hence the lack of role models in such areas.
Guidance and counseling programmes Lack of or poor guidance and counseling in schools accelerates the rate at which girls drop out of school. Girls approaching adolescence stage need guidance on how to handle the physical and psychological changes taking place in their bodies. In most pupil interviews conducted, girls revealed that they had not been prepared to deal with changes in their bodies by either parents or teachers. However, some reported having been taught about menstruation by their home science teacher. This subject has been scrapped from the syllabus. Most girls got periods with shock and surprise. The issue of menstruation is still a mystery and a no discussion zone between mothers and daughters. In a few exceptional cases, mothers were said to have prepared their girls but girls never asked them for sanitary wear. In Tharaka, mothers talked of having prepared their daughters.
Most schools visited lacked guidance and counseling teachers. In cases where there were, there was no program or time allocated for the sessions. Guidance and counseling teachers where they exist are untrained.
Inappropriate School Curriculum and Teacher Attitudes
In terms of pupil performance, the tendency to stereotype subjects according to gender has to be addressed at primary level, because this bias makes school less attractive to girls. Girls still suffer some bias in terms of teacher attention compared to boys; and girls’ performance in Mathematics and Sciences falls well behind that of boys. Boys are also given preference by parents when it comes to purchasing core textbooks (NPB 1998). A school curriculum geared more towards boys than to girls’ impacts negatively on girls’ performance and completion of primary school. Some teachers have a low opinion on girls’ performance. They believe that science and technical subjects should be left for boys. Such teachers were said to undermine and discourage girls in education. Some were said to use inappropriate language, which discouraged girls. In a school in Kibera, a teacher was reported to have been picking on girls accusing them of concentrating on beauty instead of education.
Lack of/ inadequate teaching/learning Facilities
In Tharaka, Kajiado and Nairobi, pupils reported not having enough learning materials. In Tharaka, textbooks were shared between 3-5 pupils. The situation was not any different in Kajiado and Nairobi. In City Council schools in Kibera, students are required to buy a desk on admission. The situation was worse off in the private schools not supported by any NGOs and some church sponsored schools in the slum where most Kibera girls attended. On top of paying Kshs. 500 a month, parents have to buy books, pencils, uniform and bags despite the FPE programme.
In Nairobi City Council schools, most are overcrowded. In some schools, a class had as many as 115 pupils. Some had to sit on the floor. In some schools, some rooms were empty with no furniture, classes had to be merged in order to be taught by one teacher. Some schools however operated on the shift system where classes were held in the morning and in the afternoon. Late enrolment/Forced repetition Late enrolment affects girls’ education in that they mature early whilst still in school. Some girls decide to drop out of school as they feel that they are too big or too old to be in school. They are also teased by teachers and colleagues who at times refer to them as mothers.
Though on a small scale, there are cases of head teachers who force the less endowed students to repeat classes more than once. Although the practice is not girl specific it seems to be having a higher toll on girls. This is because girls mature faster and in such instances they begin to feel hopeless, overgrown for their classes in relation to their classmates. The parents will be happy to conclude that educating such a girl is a waste and with the girl losing hope the obvious and easy option is marriage. Since girls mature faster than boys, making them repeat class exposes them to the possibilities of ridicule, early sex, pregnancy and eventual drop out before completion. This happens at a time when the girls have hardly acquired enough information about their bodies.
In Kajiado, forced repetition was said to be common. Teachers forced children who did not perform well to repeat.
Sanitary Facilities
Sanitation affects girls’ enrolment more than that of boys. A further deterrent to girls’ persistence in school, especially after puberty in co-educational ones, is lack of gender sensitive and culturally appropriate facilities. There is evidence that a majority of girls miss school during their menses because there are no separate toilet facilities to meet their needs. Some toilets have no doors and there is no running water. Some schools in Wajir district in N.E Kenya for example have toilets for boys and male staff but none for girls and female staff. The national pupil: toilet ratio is 52:1 (NPB, 1998), and the ratio is much worse in North Eastern Province (NEP). Classroom space in NEP is also very low, at 0.8 sq. metres per pupil, compared to 2.4 sq. metres in Eastern (NPB), meaning that education outside buildings is still evident in NEP.
Whereas some schools have adequate sanitary facilities, some are in very poor condition. In Tharaka, water was lacking in most of the schools. The pit latrines were almost full and in very poor condition thus posing a danger to the pupils. One boarding school had no bathroom for boys who had to bath in a river while girls’ dormitory had no curtains. Girls complained for lack of privacy while changing. In Kibera, some of the girls’ toilets had no doors. They were also dirty and faced the front of the school. Girls felt embarrassed to go to these toilets. In one school in Kariobangi, the toilets were locked after cleaning so that they are not made dirty. Girls were forced to use the playground or visit toilets in the neighbourhood. In another school in Kajiado, there was only one toilet for both boys and girls.
Drug and Alcohol abuse In Kibera and Kariobangi both boys and girls were said to be involved in drugs and alcohol abuse. Some boys carried drugs to school and influenced girls. Men and boys in this area used alcohol packed in mini packs and sold in the kiosks to lure girls into their rooms. Under the influence of alcohol, girls gave in and engaged in sex. Local liquor is brewed and sold in these areas. Some girls reportedly assist their mothers in selling the brew. In Kajiado and Tharaka however, this was not the case.
Indiscipline/Overage Children
In Tharaka, there were several cases of overage children who joined school on the introduction of FPE. These children were said to be indiscplined and influencing the younger ones negatively. This problem could be recurrent in all the schools where there are overage children. In Nairobi, a girl aged 12 was in class one. However, she had adapted well in her class and related well with her classmates. The presence of overage children puts the teacher in a dilemma of what method to use and what to teach. Although there is a curriculum to guide the teacher, it may be inappropriate for the overage as her needs or level of understanding may be beyond that of her peers.
CHAPTER FOUR
INTERVENTIONS
4.1 Interventions in girls education
Although educational opportunities have indeed expanded for all children in Kenya, the girl child in marginal and urban poor backgrounds still faces many obstacles because of some cultural practices and scarce resources. Because of this, many Civil Society Organizations, government departments, community members and schools have come up with strategic interventions to increase the participation of girls in education in Kenya.
4.2 School establishment and improvement
Establishment of schools for both boys and girls came out strongly as one of the interventions adopted by the government and Civil Society Organizations, in solving problems facing girls’ education. There are four schools constructed by Undugu Society, which caters for both boys and girls, located in Mathare, Ngomongo, Pumwani and Kibera. In addressing girls personal problems Undugu has social workers while female teachers in Undugu schools double up as counselors. Most organizations working in pastoral areas preferred boarding schools for girls. The Christian Children Fund (CCF) constructed two schools, Naningoi Girls Boarding School in Kajiado and Kisima in Samburu. Boarding schools are encouraged since they reduce the distance the girls have to walk between homes and schools. An example was given as follows:
Du poto Emaa an NGO in Kajiado encourages boarding schools. They have 11 boarding and 6 day schools. The day schools are mainly put up to encourage children to move to boarding schools. The main aim of the boarding schools is to save girls from walking long distances. For the luckiest children it is estimated that they cover a distance of 8 kilometers one way or 16 kilometers to and from school. These are schools around the urban centers and on the highway of Nairobi- Namanga. But for schools in the rural Maasailand, children cover a distance of about 40 kilometers. Because of the distance and the dangers encountered on the way to and from school, boys are encouraged to go to school while girls stay at home (Key Informant: BEF, Nairobi)
In Tharaka, Mwingi, Kwale and Malindi, where Action Aid Kenya operates, girls’ education is affected by long distance between schools and homes. Other problems related to the long distance are insecurity and rape. Action Aid Kenya addresses these problems by, establishing feeder or catchment schools located between primary schools and homes. These schools run from class 1-4. The aim is to give the pupils, particularly girls’ time to grow old enough to walk to the full primary schools.
The Kibera Slum Education Programme (KISEP) an umbrella of three Community Based Organizations and Dupoto E Maa in Kajiado, provide school facilities and expand existing school structures to accommodate more girls. They support schools by providing teaching and learning materials, textbooks, chalks, flipcharts, pens, and manila papers. They also provide furniture, desks, chairs, tables and cupboards. Dupoto E maa in addition, provides beds and mattresses to boarding schools. In fact two of the schools that were visited in Kajiado had received such support from Dupoto E Maa. Save the Children Canada gave out school bags to the top ten girls last term in one of the schools sampled in Tharaka Nithi. Community members in Kajiado use local materials to increase facilities in schools like constructing toilets and dormitories.
The Aga khan Foundation has a program that targets improvement of teaching methodologies in primary schools. The programme focuses on re-adjusting the methodologies to be gender sensitive and targets public schools. Each teacher is allocated to a mentor. The Aga Khan Foundation has a technical team of five qualified persons who provide mentoring to the teachers. The five-team members include persons in charge of, gender, monitoring, evaluation, documentation and mobilization. The mobilization mentor deals with issues pertaining to school management. The Aga Khan Foundation came up with a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Teachers service Commission to train their teachers as mentors. The training takes place at the Shanzu Teachers College in Mombasa during school holidays.
On the introduction of FPE, the Aga Khan Foundation had to refocus their approach to the school improvement programme. Children in schools became too many, yet teachers were not trained to deal with large numbers, different levels of ability, and ages admitted during the introduction of FPE. As a consequence, schools started to lose some enroled children.
In one school, we lost 60 pupils within a month as the older pupils failed to cope with ridicule from younger ones. The most affected were big girls (Key Informant: Aga khan Foundation, Nairobi)
The Aga Khan Foundation initiates programmes as a response to a community’s request. For example, they started a programme with the Muslim community in Kwale District to integrate academics with the values of the community. Initially these people took their children to the mosque and madrassa classes where they just recited the Quran and got married at age 10. On realization of this, the Aga Khan Foundation identified this as a needy area and visited the communities for verification. They then came up with an integrated curriculum combining both the Islamic and secular teachings as a form of attracting parents to take their children specifically girls to school since their religion was now part of the curriculum. To promote retention and transition of girls in schools in this area (Kwale), the Aga Khan Foundation trains most of the girls as teachers after primary or secondary schooling.
The Girl Child Network operating in Coast Province, Kwale district, has a similar programme of identifying mentors to act as role models to girls in schools. However, unlike the Aga Khan Foundation that uses government teachers as mentors, they Identify and use role models through the provincial and district education officers. The Girl Child Network secretariat identifies these mentors.
Formation of gender sensitization clubs in schools has improved girls’ participation in schooling. The Child Welfare Society of Kenya and the Basic Education Fund, together with pupils in AIC girls boarding school in Kajiado, practice this intervention. These clubs play a role of creating awareness on the rights of the girl child. Some clubs, especially those sponsored by Basic Education Fund in Mbeere have enabled orphaned children both boys and girls to acquire education by paying for their school needs. Still in Mbeere Club members sensitize parents on the importance of girls education.
The government together with Oxfam support mobile schools in North Eastern Province. Oxfam supports the Nomadic Primary Health Care and Mobile School in Wajir. The schools take care of the educational needs of the children of the nomadic pastoralists.
All the head teachers interviewed concurred that they engage in several activities within the school to promote girl’s education. They include:
• Discouraging female genital mutilation which leads to early marriages for girls
• Inviting role models to address girls
• Holding seminars with parents on girl child education
• Provision of Guidance and counseling to girls
• Giving presents to girls who perform well to promote their morale in schooling and to encourage others
Involving girls in income generating clubs such as the 4K clubs with a view of giving them finances to meet their needs
4.3 Advocacy
Government officials and Civil Society Organizations engage in advocacy and sensitization work to improve girls’ education. In conducting advocacy work, several strategies are employed. For example, Action Aid Kenya, (AAK) organizes trainings in children’s Act and harmful practices. In Narok district, AAK focuses their training on early marriages to counter the cultural practice of marrying off young girls immediately after circumcision. During these trainings, chiefs are mandated to safeguard the interests of the girl child. Surprisingly most parents are not aware of the children rights as indicated below:
The communities were shocked to hear that they could go to jail for marrying off their daughters (Key Informant: AAK Nairobi)
Dupoto Emaa together with the Anglican Church of Kenya (ACK) in Kajiado collaborates with the provincial administration to fight for the rights of the children. Chiefs and the district commissioner retrieve schoolgirls from forced marriages. Girls are also sensitized to run to chiefs to report cases of abduction and forced marriages. Forums are organized to address the education of the girl child in the rural areas. Such foras enlighten girls on their rights. As a result many girls have rejected forced marriages and have been enroled in schools. The following are voices of girls saved from early/forced marriages by the provincial administration:
…It was in the year 2000 and I was 11 years, when a friend of my grandfather came to him to be given a girl. Grandfather notified father about the request but my father did not say a word. Among the Maasai first-born children belong to grand parents that is why my father did not object the request. My grandfather then arranged to give me away. My wedding was to be like on Saturday, and then two days before a friend of mine in this school (AIC Primary) advised me to refuse the marriage. Then on a Thursday before the wedding I asked for permission to visit my maternal grandmother. I used the chance to come to this school, where I was advised to go to the District Commissioner Kajiado District to report the case. The DC wrote my story and brought me to school (Key Informant: AIC Primary School, Kajiado)
And another:
I attended Engaroni primary school up to class two then my father said he had no money to educate me. I was circumcised in 1996 and stayed at home the whole year. In 1997 I got married to an old friend of my father. He was my father’s age mate. The old man (my husband) was around 40 years old. He paid dowry in terms of two cows and an unknown amount of money. My mother told me of the arrangements but I was too young to take any action. I was only 9 years old by then. Then one Saturday morning I went to the chief to report the matter. The chief came to my home (where I was married) then ordered that I should be taken back home. He was promised that I would be returned but my in-laws planned to take me somewhere else to hide me from the chief, but before their plan matured I ran away and went back to my fathers home from where the chief arranged and brought me to this school…(Key Informant: AIC Primary School, Kajiado)
The voices of the two girls and many others that were not captured indicate positive results of sensitization on the rights of the child. However, forced/early marriage is still a reality in these regions, as some girls are accepting to be married off for fear of being cursed by parents.
The Basic Education Fund supports women lobby groups composed of professionals throughout Kajiado district. The lobby groups campaign against retrogressive cultural aspects like the female genital mutilation and early marriages. Government officials who are not from the Maasai community support this strategy. They argue that it is easier for the community to listen to their own people. Lobbying has led to changes on the circumcision calendar. Earlier on circumscion was conducted any time of the year, but after sensitization the ceremony is performed during the December school holidays that are long enough for healing. Culturally the female circumcision term is three months, but this has been reduced to one month to allow girls to go back to school. However, members of the lobby groups revealed that, sensitization in some regions of the district need involvement of men since they are decision makers in society. Professional women are sometimes dismissed as ‘educated or town women’ who do not uphold culture.
Ntanira Na Mugambo, meaning ‘circumcise with a word of mouth’, is a Community Based Organisation (CBO) operating in Tharaka District. It was started in 1996 by some women on realisation that female genital mutilation was very rampant in the community and was the course of early marriages hence high rate of girls’ dropout. The CBO focuses on creation of awareness and the fight against female genital mutilation. This is done through a developed curriculum, which covers harmful traditional practices, personal hygiene, boy/men/girl relationship, self-esteem, drug abuse, decision-making, peer pressure, reproductive system and STI/HIV/AIDS. Through this programme many girls have been saved from FGM.
Organization of foras for girls to discuss their experiences is used as an advocacy strategy to improve their schooling. Action Aid Kenya organized a girls’ forums this year where girls had the opportunity to put forward their problems. Among the problems that came out strongly were sexual harassment, canning in schools, domestic chores and girls being used to work for teachers. In the forums, girls participants from Western Kenya brought out issues of rape and molestation. The girls wrote letters to their Members of Parliaments and the Ministry of Education Science and Technology appealing for change of the gender policy. Currently, Action Aid Kenya is planning on the best strategy to counter the problems mentioned.
To overcome the problem of bad peers, movies and bars near schools and homes in Mukuru, Nairobi, the managers of St. Elizabeth Mukuru sensitize parents on the need of girls’ education during school, class and annual general meetings. They also enlighten the parents on hindrances to girls’ education like pornographic video shows. They ask chiefs and parents to discourage children from visiting such places. Parents are advised against giving children money, as it is an enticement of going to the video shows.
4.4 The re-entry programme
Girls abandoning school due to early pregnancy was repeatedly cited as a serious factor affecting their schooling. In the recent past the government came up with a policy allowing girls who have given birth to be re admitted into schools. The Lutheran World Federation (LWF) through UNHCR Funds established a project to cater for girls who had dropped out of the mainstream primary education system and wish to return to school.
The Western Kenya Girl Child Network chapter has helped teenage mothers to return to formal education after delivery. In Moipei primary school in Kajiado there was a case of a girl who had given birth and gone back to the same class. But still much needs to be done to enforce this policy as many girls who give birth shy away from going back to school in fear of being stigmatized by other pupils and teachers.
4.5 Girls Education Movement
The Girls Education Movement (GEM) is an intervention that Women Educational Researchers of Kenya (WERK) employs to improve participation of girls in schooling. It is a movement led by young people supposed to transform negative attitudes towards girls’ education in Africa. It is a participatory movement designed to give children and young girls maximum opportunity to develop and express their own ideas without adult interference. It came out from a meeting of professionals in Kampala in 2000. WERK is the focal point for GEM in this country. WERK is working towards partnering with UNHCR to have GEM clubs in primary schools and refugee camps. Three young Kenyan girls, who are members of WERK, participated in the workshop in Uganda. During this workshop they were trained as trainers. As a result they are training other girls in the country.
4.6 Alternative approaches to education
In promoting girls education, Action Aid Kenya (AAK) came up with an alternative approach to education, the Non Formal Education (NFE) approach in Samburu, which is predominantly a pastoralist region. They conduct evening and after work classes. Initially, the project targeted older children of both sexes, but it turned out that 65 per cent of the pupils were girls of school going age left at home to milk and to take care of the weaker animals during times of drought as boys take animals far from homes in search for pasture.
Further still, AAK has assisted in the establishment of out of school centers in Samburu next to the Manyattas (traditional houses of the Samburu) in collaboration with the government. The Ministry of Education runs these centers and they enroll girls who are disadvantaged in education in this region. Most teachers in these centers are formal schoolteachers employed by the government. They are motivated through incentives like trainings in multigrade teaching and exposure visits to other regions of the world. AAK gave the teachers a grant of kshs.175, 000 to start an Income Generating Project (IGP).
4.7 Poverty reduction strategies
Poverty came out as one of the factors affecting girls’ education. To solve this problem some civil society organizations have encouraged school management committees to be involved in Income Generating Activities (IGAs). The Basic Education Fund (BEF) exclusively mentioned this intervention. FAWEK, which partners with BEF in Mbeere and Meru districts provide financial assistance to school managers. The assistance is popularly known as seed money (money to start off). The money is used to support the gender sensitization clubs. Club members are encouraged to start income generating activities to sustain them. The money generated from the activities is used for meeting club needs. Club members are engaged in creative arts as a form of passing messages on the rights of the girl child and the need to educate girls. They also generate income from such performances.
BEF and Oxfam empower poor parents economically through financing of small businesses. Their aim is to give them an economic base from which they can pay for the education of girls. Oxfam partners with Wema Center in Mombasa and Pendekezo Letu to provide educational and other basic needs to girls retrieved from the streets. Parents of these girls are given financial support for a period of three years to start income generating activities.
In Kajiado, which is predominantly pastoral, chiefs try to reduce poverty by sensitizing the community to supplement animal keeping with farming so as to get food and school fees for children. Dupoto E maa also working in the same district tries to address the problem of poverty by encouraging head teachers of schools to register an association for lobbying the Ministry of Education. They are encouraged to collectively present problems facing children in their schools, such as of school feeding and reduction of fees for boarding schools.
Action Aid Kenya (AAK) establishes school resource bases in which levy saving strategies are established. Before the introduction of FPE, this fund helped the poor households in paying school levies. But with the new FPE programme the fund is used to buy other school needs not provided by the government. In this project, AAK gives a donation of a certain amount of money and the community raises half the amount. The arrangement can be translated to a ratio of 1:2. The community is asked to come up with set targets for the finances. From this fund, schools draw budgets for purchasing teaching and learning materials and payment of watchmen’s salaries. The aim of the project is to encourage schooling of girls normally affected by poverty situations at the household level. The project also encourages the spirit of working together. The project which is still in operation, has lasted for four years.
4.8 Sponsorships
Sponsorship is used as another intervention in girls’ education. The Girl Child Network and the Christian Children Fund sponsor girls from poor backgrounds. With the introduction of free primary education, the girl Child Network turned their focus to sponsoring girls in secondary schools, while the Christian Children Fund (CCF) now buys uniforms, books and other school needs for children from needy backgrounds. In an interview with pupils from Moipei and Oloosuyan Primary schools both in Kajiado, it was revealed that some of the participants were beneficiaries of CCF.
The Young Muslim Association gives preference to girls in bursary awards, while Oxfam supports a partner in Wajir which provides uniforms for school girls and puts up separate toilets for girls in schools. On the same point of sponsorships, Pupils of Mashimoni Squatters Primary School in Kibera reported that they receive clothes, uniforms, bags and food from the Calvary Evangelistic group. This group offers breakfast, lunch and supper to orphans. All sponsored children have their meals in the school.
Sinaga Center in Nairobi deals with rescuing domestic child workers and sponsors bright pupils in the ABC class to formal education in boarding schools. The center has a withdrawal and counseling program where girls are withdrawn from working as house girls. After counseling they are taught basic literacy, how to read and write, before they are sponsored to join formal schooling.
The Education officer in Tharaka confirmed that the government has emphasized on bursary funds particularly in the district in order to reduce dropout rates of girls occasioned by high poverty levels.
4.9 Research findings and actions
Researches have been conducted on development issues to find out the challenges facing girls’ education and how best they can be addressed. It is out of such researches that appropriate action can be taken. Action Aid Kenya, Oxfam and Women Educational Researchers of Kenya (WERK) are all involved in carrying out different researches in girls’ education. To translate research findings into action, WERK disseminates the results as fast as possible. Dissemination is done to all relevant parties including schools.
We go back to the field to disseminate our findings. We have done that on each and every research that we have carried out. We disseminate to schools and other places where we feel action can be taken to improve girls’ education (Key Informant: WERK Nairobi).
Action Aid Kenya and Oxfam for example, react to research findings by taking action. For example, Oxfam engaged a consultant to find out the best practices in education of the pastoralists with an aim of replicating in one of their regions of operation.
4.10 Legal representation
ANNPCAN, CRADLE and CADEC have assisted girls whose parents are able but had refused to pay school fees, by providing them with legal aid and representation in court.
4.11 School feeding programme
The Arid and Semi Arid Areas (ASAL) have their own peculiar needs especially in girls’ education. A small number of girls in these areas are enroled in schools because of the long distances they have to walk to schools. Girls in this case are not allowed to go to school because they cannot afford to go back home for lunch. Special interventions have in the past been put in place to improve enrolment in ASAL regions. These interventions include a school-feeding programme in Kajiado by the World Food Programme. However, this programme ends this year. Some of the schools visited, which have been benefiting from this programme were no longer getting food. In Kibera slums Oxfam, has a feeding programme for girls from poor backgrounds. In both situations, girls benefit from the programme considering that they are most likely to be withdrawn from school in cases of long distances and poverty.
4.12 Centers of excellence
Four FAWE chapters, Kenya, Rwanda, Tanzania and Senegal have been involved in the establishment of centers of excellence. These schools are designed to provide a conducive environment for quality learning and teaching. The schools demonstrate how information, knowledge and experience accumulated on girl issues can be used to formulate, implement and monitor policies and practices that promotes girls education (FAWE, News magazine, 2nd April to June 2001).
This intervention is common in Kajiado District that has rampant problems of parents especially fathers marrying off young girls. All actors in education in this area are working towards reduction of this practice. In fact all the CSOs, government officials, community members and leaders that participated in the study confided that they are engaged in rescuing girls from early marriages. The district has special schools, which are used, as ‘rescue’ centers or centers of excellence. The schools include, AIC Kajiado, Illbisil primary school and Naningoi. In a focus group discussion three chiefs from the district commented that:
On the problem of early/forced marriages we have one organization that helps us (FAWE). When we hear of a girl getting married off we retrieve her and enrol her at AIC girls a FAWE sponsored school.
4.13 Parents’ involvement in school Management.
Community members in Kajiado district commented that, they support girls’ education by being involved in school decisions. Most of the community members interviewed were parents in Illbisil Primary School. They revealed that, each class has a representative from the parent’s body who ensures that girls do not drop out of school. The parents that took part in the study had come to Illbissil primary school to discuss issues of their daughters with the head teacher. In the words of the headmaster:
We have 7 big girls in this school who are notorious of sneaking out and going to visit their boyfriends. Today we have a meeting with their parents to sensitize them on bringing the girls to the boarding section under the school committee sponsorship. The school has already taken 4 from the group (Key Informant: Illbisil Primary School, Kajiado)
From the discussion, community members revealed that they collaborate with the teachers to solve girls’ problems. Most participants indicated that mothers are more supportive of girls’ education than fathers. In an interview with one of the women leaders in the district it was reported that mothers are now aware of the importance of girls’ education as shown by their willingness to take up chores traditionally performed by girls. Mothers are looking after animals as girls go to school. Discussions with girls revealed that mothers are supportive of girls education and they assist daughters to escape from forced marriages.
4.11 Introduction of Free Primary Education (FPE)
Government officials interviewed mentioned the introduction of FPE as an intervention in girls’ education. FPE solved the problem of parents paying school levies, which was a burden to many considering that almost a half of the population lives below the poverty line. The key informant from ANNPCAN supported them. Head teachers support the FPE programme, which they acknowledged is an intervention in promotion of both girls and boys. They have adopted the following strategies for the success of FPE:
Establishing Guidance and counseling programmes particularly of the over aged girls.
Increasing learning materials.
Involving parents in school matters. Parents recruited a teacher in one of the schools visited in Tharaka.
Urgent construction of semi-permanent structures and addition of furniture and books to cater for new entrants.
Dividing classes into double streams and introduction of shift system.
Encouraging sharing of textbooks.
Working overtime in marking of pupils work
4.14 Networking
It was one of the proposals at the Dakar conference that international and bilateral agencies shall work in partnership with governments and civil society organizations to enhance the achievement of EFA.It is for this reason that both government officials and CSOs participants acknowledged networking as an intervention in girls’ education. In an interview with the chief advisor to schools in Nairobi, it was revealed that:
The government works with NGOs.For example, the government has been working with UNICEF on girl child friendly teaching methods and quality education. UNICEF conducted Training of Trainers to teach them on child friendly methodologies so that they could train others (Key informant: City Hall, Nairobi).
Plan International is working closely with the government to solve problems of girls linked to facilities like toilets. Plan has helped to built toilets and classrooms in Dagoreti Division in Nairobi, Kwale, Kilifi, Thika, Kiambu, Kiumu and Embu. In Tharaka it was established that the government works closely with Ntanira na Mugambo, Save the Children Canada which insists that girls must be given priority in education. Generally, Save the Children Canada focuses on children and covers the whole district with reference to sensitizing them on, FGM, HIV/AIDS and general health and education of children.
4.15 Monitoring and evaluation
The Voluntary Service Overseas (VSO) interventions in addressing girls’ problems are seen from their monitoring and evaluation results which are conducted through visits and through the NGOs/CBOs on the ground. Through monitoring and evaluation they have witnessed continuous improvement for girls. The informant confirmed that girls’ enrolment in subjects such as physics has improved and their grades in performance have improved too. VSO also organized a science week for girls where experiences were shared.
4.16 Policies and Plans to Promote Girls’ Education
Policies and plans are significant in shaping the direction of girls’ education in any country. Two important actors in girls’ education were asked to state how they are promoting girls education through policies and plans.
i) Civil Society Organizations and
ii) Government officials
i) Civil Society Organizations
Most organizations reported being aware of policies in education, but they were not aware of specific policies that targeted girls’ education. In cases where they knew of some, they were said to be on paper and not implemented on the ground.
In many schools, girls’ toilets have no privacy as they lacked doors and face the same direction with those of boys. There is need to engender the education policy in regard to girls’ toilets. The Girl Child Network (GCN) influences policy through lobbying for the right of the girl child. GCN has often given its memorandum on education for all during events such as Education For All week and the day for the African child.
VSO acknowledged being aware that the government does indeed encourage girls’ education through its policy. He cited the current education bill, which states that the government shall encourage education of disadvantaged groups such as girls and orphans. He said that VSO has not been involved much in promoting such policies but are sometimes involved in debates concerning education through invitation by the ministry of education and Elimu Yetu Coalition.
CARE has formulated policies for the organization and for the government. Recently, CARE restructured its programs and came up with a new strategic plan to have Basic Education Fellowship Programme (BEF) Girl Child Network (GCN) and HIV/HACI, Hope for African Child Initiative under one sector called Civil Society strengthening. It links all the three areas to programme issues on girl child. It is a holistic programme targeting the social needs of children.
Like most civil society organization there is a gender policy in CARE that ensures equity of sexes at all levels of operation. BEF played a major role in the development of this policy. It was part of the gender-working group. BEF has also been the model of gender equity of all the CARE programmes. Only BEF has trained its partners on gender. It also spearheaded the development of a CARE –Kenya gender manual used by managers and a gender manual in education for her partners.
On government policies, BEF has been involved in developing Universal Primary Education (UPE) implementation plan.
CARE feels that the government should have a strategic plan to address education and hopes to lobby for this in its meetings with government officials. During UPE meetings held early this year, the BEF informant reported that it was difficult for the participants to make meaningful contributions, as there was no strategic plan laid out by the government to guide them.
For government policies on girls education, the Women Educational Researchers of Kenya (WERK) knew of the existence of the re-entry policy for girl mothers, but wasn’t sure of how effective it is, because some research findings indicated that girls fear they’ll be laughed at if they went back to school after getting babies. Other issues of concern were the distance to school and lack of minders to take care of the baby when the child-mother goes to school.
ANPCCAN reported being aware of organizations trying as much as possible to mainstream gender in their programmes. Such organizations give priority to girls when awarding scholarships. According to ANNPCAN the legal framework for the provision of FPE promotes girls’ education because parents who were reluctant to take girls to school are now forced to do so. The organization has been involved in collective lobbying for girls education with specific networks like GCN and has highlighted issues on the importance of education of the girl child in the media. It was also involved in the lobbying for the passing of the Children’s Bill where members discussed with parliamentarians and sensitized them on the importance of passing that bill in parliament.
Action Aid Kenya (AAK) does not target girls specifically. However, girls are consciously considered in all their programmes although the organization does not have a policy on girls’ education.
Although AAK sponsored the EFA planning process, the organization feels that the government does not have a policy on girls’ education. In the EFA process, the Ministry of Education failed to capture the need to mainstream gender in education. According to Action Aid Kenya the declaration of FPE is not enough but there must be strategies laid down to enforce its implementation. There hasn’t been any major planning of girls’ education apart from the master plan and the Koech report that has since been shelved. However, the Ministry of Education in collaboration with the World Bank is trying to come up with a plan on girls’ education.
On policy issues Oxfam reported that it has coined its policy around gender equity and diversity. Equity and diversity were elaborated to mean looking at the men in a different environment, since there are times when men are marginalized. Girls’ education is a significant policy in Oxfam considering that it was made a key issue between 2002 -2005. It is one of the strategic areas that Oxfam is focusing on for the coming three years. Oxfam is putting resources into this programme as a commitment to promoting girls education.
Oxfam is lobbying the government through the Provincial Director of Education North Eastern Province to change the current policies on education in pastoral areas. Examples of policies that Oxfam wants to be changed are:
The government’s policy of putting up stationary schools. These schools are irrelevant in a nomadic pastoralist environment. Such schools only serve civil servant workers and settled people but not the nomadic community members.
Many organizations together with the government put up boarding schools to serve children of the pastoralists, but with time they lost popularity because some parents declined to take their children to these schools with an assumption that they were being taken away. Boarding schools were also rejected because parents did not see the need of an education that did not teach children pastoralism, which is their way of life. Also, when families move with animals children in boarding schools suffer since they have to trace their parents during school holidays. These children especially girls suffer because of insecurity on the way caused by bandits, yet the girl child in the pastoral community is tightly safeguarded.
Oxfam therefore suggested that the government should come up with a policy that will make the education curriculum more responsive to the pastorsalit way of life.
One of FAWEs strategic objective is to influence policy formulation by working closely with the MOEST. FAWE in collaboration with other CSOs lobbied for certain policies like the re-admission policy of girls who have given birth. Although the policy was recognized by the government it is yet to reach many people and it is FAWEs agenda to disseminate. Currently they are lobbying the government to put this in writing.
The government has taken an affirmative action on bursary allocation because of FAWEs lobbying. There is an allocation of two million Kenyan shillings for girls in every province and this money is channeled through FAWEK. However, they are still lobbying for a bigger allocation. Another affirmative action already considered by the government because of FAWEs lobbying is the admission of girls to university education. They are taken with one point lower than boys.
On the EFA process FAWEK came out strongly on gender mainstreaming, they organized workshops on gender, printed documents on sector reforms and education. The team dealing with EFA and draft education bill has already been taken through training on gender and girl child issues by FAWEK.
ii) Government
This study was also to find out the existing government policies and plans to promote girls education in consideration that the government is the main actor in policy formulation and implementation. It was noted that there are policies on girls’ education although they are not documented in one report. They are scattered in other policy documents like the commissions/committees in education, development plans and sessional papers. The Ministry of education is in the process of developing a policy document to address educational issues in general. The following objectives have been set to eliminate gender disparities in access, transition, retention and performance in education.
The objectives are to:
1. Address specific problems of access, retention, transition and performance of the boy and girl child in the education system
2. Promote and support alternative systems of basic education in collaboration with CSOs and other stake holders
3. Improve participation of children with disability especially the girl child in both special and vocational trainings
4. Ensure that literacy and post literacy materials are gender responsive and easily available to all learners (MOEST, draft copy, 2003)
The draft copy on education had a list of eight strategies that the ministry is proposing in order to achieve the above objectives. However, this study confirmed that six of those proposed strategies have been implemented.
Implemented strategies
i) Provision of free primary basic education
The Kenyan government in January 2003 adopted this strategy. All the government officials interviewed acknowledged the policy of free primary education as one that is promoting girls education. Introduction of FPE outlawed school levies that were burdening parents thus making them not to enroll girls in schools. The government provides funds for buying learning materials and basic infrastructural materials so that the parents are relieved of the burden of cost sharing which made many pupils particularly girls to be either out of school or learn with difficulties.
ii) Restructuring education programmes to make them gender responsive in curricular content, training and learning materials
The government is changing the curricular content to be gender sensitive through the Kenya Institute of Education that deals with curriculum development. Examples in learners’ books and teachers’ guides are more gender responsive than before. Teachers in schools are trained to create a friendly atmosphere for girls learning both inside and outside the classroom, while those in the field are receiving in-service courses provided by civil society organizations that are working closely with the government. For example, the Aga Khan Foundation trains government teachers in Mombassa to be sensitive to the needs of girls.
iii) Streamlining procedures for equity in existing loans and bursary schemes and school feeding programmes to target needy boys and girls
This is one of the government policies to provide bursaries for girls. This was reported in Kajiado and Tharaka Nithi. FAWEK also confirmed that there is an allocation of kshs, 2,000,000 to girls as bursaries in every province. The government has also been working through the World Food Programme to provide food (School feeding programme) to the primary schools. This programme covers many schools in the Arid and Semi Arid Locations.
iv) Encouraging community mobilization and sensitization in support for the girl child as a basis for influencing socio-cultural and household dynamics to overcome the differential treatment of boys and girls.
Government partners and civil society organizations, play a major role of mobilizing the community and sensitizing them on the importance of educating the girl child. In most cases the two actors work together as in the case of Kajiado where the government is actively involved in retrieving girls from forced marriages. In all the locations visited, community members are actively involved in school matters. They form part of the school committees in addition to supplementing school facilities like toilets and dormitories.
v) Encouraging development of effective strategies for increased participation of girls in science and technical education
Teachers are very instrumental in ensuring that pupils learn and grasp concepts, it is because of this that the government made it a policy to train and in-service teachers on new methodologies of teaching mathematics and science. The methodology referred to as, Science and Mathematic as a subject (SMAS) is aimed at changing the teacher’s attitudes towards girls and science subjects. Girls are also sensitized and encouraged through workshops and other fora to take up science and technical subjects.
vi) Reorienting education provision towards the needs of children with disabilities
In the recent past the government came up with a policy of expanding the existing facilities in order to take care of the needs of the disabled children. Most primary schools have a unit for children with special needs. Some of the schools visited had this unit. For example, AIC primary had a unit for the physically challenged while Illbissil Primary school had a unit for the hearing impaired. In cases where children are disabled it is mainly the girl child who suffers neglect, but with the provision of these facilities disabled girl children are now accessing education. Teachers have been trained on how to handle these special cases. Right now their curriculum is integrative where children with special needs no longer learn in isolation. Sometimes they are put together with normal learners who are at their level.
Proposed Strategies pending to be implemented
Producing innovative and cost effective literacy and post literacy materials aimed at the acquisition and retention of the learned skills
Establishing a monitoring and follow up mechanism for gender information on school enrolment, dropouts, children out of school and designing appropriate measures to address their needs
4.17 Achievements in Girls education
Through the efforts made by all the CSOs, community members and government departments that participated in the study, girls’ education has improved in various ways as shown below:
There has been a sharp increase in the number of girls going to school.
CSOs have shared concerns in girls’ education with the government which has led to positive actions toward girls’ education like drafting of a policy document that has sections on girls education.
Creation of awareness amongst girls on their rights through advocacy and girl clubs consequently leading to inculcation of confidence and self esteem among girls. Sensitized girls are no longer shy and withdrawn. This was proved during field visits where a big difference in behavior among girls in AIC primary school in Kajiado that has been a focus of sensitization groups as compared to girls in other schools was noticed. Those of AIC Kajiado were more open and confident.
Reducing distance for girls between homes and schools in pastoral areas by putting up boarding, mobile and feeder schools.
Girls leading in examination performance as seen in Kajiado and Mashimoni Squatters Primary school, girls in the supported programs are excelling in National examinations
There is a reduction in corporal punishment that affects girls schooling. In addition, the government banned corporal punishment in schools.
Legal aid and representation in court for girls whose able parents have declined to pay their school fees
Involvement of girls in sports and other programmes traditionally perceived to be for boys, which enhances their talents within the education system. Some have ventured in trainings, which were formally dominated by men such as mechanics and welding.
There are also cases of re-entry for those who had dropped out due to pregnancy.
Transformation of communities to start valuing girls’ education. Initially some communities were reluctant but now they are eager to take children to school.
The building of leaders / future leaders. The girls’ that are getting educated will be societies future leaders.
CHAPTER FIVE
BEST PRACTICES
5.1 Centers of excellence
FAWE-Kenya takes a holistic approach in enhancing girls’ education. Right from the inception of a project, it involves the community in all her activities. Communities act as agents and advocates for their projects. They are also partners as they provide locally available materials needed. FAWE uses research findings to identify areas of intervention. These researches can be their own or those conducted by other organizations or research institutions. After identifying the problem, they study it and come up with suitable intervention. The centers of excellence were as a result of the finding that girls are forced into marriage in exchange for cows. They established rescue centers for such girls.
AIC girls’ Kajiado is a government public school turned into a Center of Excellence where girls rescued from forced marriages are admitted. Currently, the center has 60 girls. The school emphasizes on holistic quality education which is achieved through use of regularly in-servicing of teachers. The teachers are trained on gender sensitivity with emphasis on creation of girl friendly teaching environment and updated on teaching methods. They are also trained on basic counseling skills. The school committee is trained on management. The girls are empowered on their rights.
AIC Kajiado is also a model of a girls’ school. The school provides a girl friendly teaching and learning environment. The girls are empowered and full of confidence in themselves. Through girls clubs, girls are able to discuss issues affecting them and identify solutions.
FAWE identified a gap between rescued girls and their parents and has now started reconciling girls with their parents. They do these through consultations with the chief and parents. They have empowered chiefs on the importance of girls’ education. Girls can now turn to the chief for assistance.
5.2 Rescuing Domestic Workers and Giving Them an Education
Sinaga center is the only one of its kind in Kenya. This organization rescues girls from domestic child labour and offers them a chance in education and training. Sinaga targets girls aged between 6-18 year olds. The girls are trained on their rights and taught basic literacy. Girls between 6-13 years are taught basic literacy and numeracy while those between 14-16 are trained on skills. Sinaga targets orphans. Those who excel in the ABC class are integrated to formal schools where they continue with education. Since most are orphans, they are sent to boarding schools. Girls in skills training sit for recognized examinations like pitman for typing, and K.I.E grade 1 test for cookery. Sinaga attaches the trainees to companies for on job training. The organization also employs some of its graduates. It also runs an income-generating project where foods made by the cookery pupils are sold.
5.3 Bringing Schools Nearer Home.
Distance between schools and home is a very far in some areas like Tharaka and Samburu districts. During the rainy season, rivers are flooded hence children cannot go to school. Parents fear taking their daughters to school due to the prevailing insecurity in the area and fear of rape. This has led to Action Aid establishing feeder/catchment schools located between primary schools and home. These schools cater for young children who may not be able to cover the long distance to primary schools. They run from class 1-4 after which pupils join the full primary school, by then they are older. AAK has established feeder schools in Tharaka, Mwingi, Kwale and Malindi Districts. This has led to increased enrolment in upper primary schools.
5.4 Alternative Approaches to education
AAK has come up with alternative approaches to education like NFE e.g. in Samburu where there are evening classes and after work classes. Initially, the project targeted older children. It turned out that 65% of the pupils were girls owing to the fact that during times of drought, boys are trusted more to take animals far seeking for pastures. Girls were left to look after the milking and weaker animals and they therefore missed schooling. Evening classes and after work classes have therefore given a chance to girls for education.
5.5 Establishment of Boarding Schools
Boarding schools as a solution to distance between schools and homes seemed to be working. Dupoto Emaa, CCF and FAWE-Kenya all working in Narok and Kajiado encouraged the establishment of boarding schools. The organization currently runs 11 boarding schools. Boarding schools not only saves girls from walking long distances but also provide a conducive learning environment. Dangers encountered by girls on their way to and from school are also taken care of by boarding schools. Parents have no reason to quote dangers encountered by girls on their way to school as reasons for keeping their daughters out of school. One of the issues emerging from the field was lack of reading space at home. Some girls even talked of lack of sleeping space. Boarding schools also serve as rescue centers for girls targeted for forced marriage.
CHAPTER SIX
RECOMMENDATIONS
6.1 STRATEGIES THAT SHOULD BE PUT IN PLACE IN ORDER TO IMPROVE GIRLS’ EDUCATION IN KENYA
6.1.1 Government
To ensure effective implementation of gender responsive policies, the government should spearhead public education campaigns through print and electronic media. Gender sensitization including issues of sexual harassment of girls should be continued targeting educational policy makers, managers (provincial and district educational administrators, headteachers, inspectors, PTAs, BOG) and other practitioners.
Provision of adequate physical facilities: Construction of gender responsive physical facilities should be made mandatory in schools by the government. Specific emphasis should be placed on having adequate sanitation facilities. Provision of basic social amenities such as water and health clinics nearer to schools and locating schools nearer to communities will go along way to reduce distance girls travel to schools. This in turn will reduce parental concerns on their daughters’ safety.
HIV/AIDS: The Kenyan government must treat the threat posed by HIV/AIDS to adolescent and teenage girls seriously and provide policy on HIV/AIDS to guide action, looking at innovative ways of protecting educational institutions and learners from the effects of HIV/AIDS, and coordinate interventions. Emphasis must be placed on reproductive and sexual health education programmes in regular education in both in and out of school, including the promotion of appropriate integration of sexual and reproductive health services including family planning, maternal health care and STI/HIV/AIDS prevention and care. There is need for flexible schooling for girls in areas that are worst hit by HIV/AIDS (urban slums and districts like Busia, Kisumu and Mombasa) for orphans and young children affected and infected by HIV/AIDS to ensure that their education, health and social needs are taken care of, and review existing laws and introduce stiff penalties against persons who commit crimes of a sexual nature.
Because the HIV/AIDS pandemic is constantly evolving, monitoring its effects provides essential information to guide policy and programme development. This calls for the government to put in place systems that regularly collect and disseminate information on health and socio-economic impact of HIV/AIDS on families and particularly the girl child. Accurate information is essential for assistance to children (girls included) in the most seriously affected districts or slum areas. The next step is to identify appropriate response actions and develop strategies and interventions aimed at keeping children alive, in school and in good health. There is an urgent need to get more AIDS affected girls into school, or into alternative and especially supportive basic educational programmes.
The government should allow young married girls in the education system. The current tendency to exclude married girls from schooling, both by schools and families (including spouses) should be discouraged. The policy should recognize the right of all children to education, regardless of their marital status.
A comprehensive policy on sexual harassment and abuse of girls in school need to be reinforced and implemented by the government. Strict policies should be inflicted on the offender be they teachers or boys in the same school. The current tendency to victimize the victims should be treated as an offence in itself. It makes absolutely no sense to suspend a girl who has been harassed by a teacher.
It is not enough to interdict a teacher who has defiled/raped/sodomised the pupils. The TSC Act should be implemented to enable relevant authorities to proceed with criminal charges against such teachers. At the same time medical expenses of the girl-victim incurred as a result of the abuse must be met by the offender.
The laws relating to rape and defilement should be reviewed to make them consistent with the gravity of the crime commited. In addition to imprisonment, fine should be imposed on the rapist. The fine should cover the costs of medical bills incurred as a result of the rape, and the maintenance of the girl child should pregnancy result from such act.
The re-entry policy needs to be elaborated and clarified. Access to lactating mothers to school should be facilitates, including provision of alternative learning opportunities to ensure academic continuity for the period pregnant / or lactating girls are out of school.
Formulate special re-entry policies for girls: The Ministry of Education should be key in the implementation of FPE to support girls who left school due to pregnancy, child labour and disadvantaged girls in terms of food and other factors. Child and gender responsive policies should be formulated to ensure that working children particularly the girl child are provided with quality education.
Costs: Even though the government introduced FPE early this year (2003), it has been documented that the direct cost of education greatly determines the chances of girls having access to school. When family resources are scarce Due to high poverty levels in most districts in Kenya, the government should support girls education through special funds e.g. bursaries set a side specifically for girls’ education and reflect this in the budget
Affirmative action policy as a short-term measure in education management, teaching and enrolment at primary and other levels of education including financial aid/bursaries for girls from the poverty stricken and marginalized districts in Kenya. The government should put in place incentives and affirmative action policies such as Girls Scholarships Programme, which offers full scholarships for girls up to the end of secondary school.
Educate /sensitize stakeholders especially the marginalized communities on the importance of girl child education. This therefore calls for government as law enforcement agency to involve parents in girl education matters, for them to feel that the girl education project is for their own good so as to make it succeed.
Address the girls’ education as a national issue. The government should enforce laws or measures to be taken on the parent, guardian or child if a child fails to go to school. Currently, there are a number of girl child who are still out of school and nothing is being done to address this.
Engender the curriculum /teaching/learning materials: Teaching and learning materials need to be revised and the school curriculum be made more gender sensitive. Stereotyping in subject allocation need to be minimized and girls be encouraged to study subjects which have been traditional male domains such as mathematics, science and technical subjects (e.g. computer).
A curriculum that is irrelevant to the needs of pupils leads to lower participation in the class. Lack of co-currucula activities to enhance the core subjects and bridge the gender gap also plays a role in keeping girls out of school. A lot of work still need to be done in this area at national levels in subjects like Science, Technical and Mathematics.
Gender mainstream in education to ensure a balance in the enrolment rates in the learning institutions. This was one of the objectives of Dakar 2000 and a lot still need to be done to achieve gender parity in education. The teachers need to be re-oriented to become more gender sensitive through training and retraining programmes.
The government did outlaw the existing cultural practices e.g. Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) but this still continue unabated in some districts in Kenya e.g. Kisii, Kuria, Nyambene, Tharaka etc. It is therefore important for the government to reinforce such laws using its networks of the provincial administration to discourage parents from circumcising their daughters as this hinders girls’ education.
Advocacy and lobbying: Strong advocacy is still needed to change people’s perception towards girls’ education especially among the marginalized/ pastoral communities. This can help to change the attitude of such communities (pastoralists) where girls education are not considered important.
The school environment: The government should create a conducive and girl child friendly learning environment in schools. The school environment should be safer and more girl friendly (e.g. separate toilet facilities for boys and girls). The state of the school itself can often determine whether girls will remain in school. There is need for adequate places in the school, as well as sanitation facilities as this greatly affects girls schooling. Distance to school also plays a major role in girls’ participation and raises issues of safety and security.
Female trained teachers: The presence of more female teachers in primary schools and in leadership positions would mean that parents will be more willing to send their daughters to school.
The Ministry of Education should come up with an education system in which there is room for wide consultations, proper training of teachers, well equipped schools with libraries and resource centers for teachers and pupils.
The teacher is a key ingredient to the improvement of quality of basic education. Under qualified and untrained teachers lack the skills to carry out their tasks effectively.
Political support: The government of the day should offer good political will in girls’ education. Leading politicians including the president should take a leading role in advocating and supporting girls’ education. The head of the state should speak out as often as possible in public on the importance of girls’ education. Since most politicians are also well respected and listened to by their respective communities, they should sensitize the public on the importance of girls’ education.
6.1.2 Other Recommendations
Increase female teachers in the marginalized communities to act as role models
Establish/put up more schools for girls in the marginalized districts like Tharaka, Kajiado, Garissa, Wajir, Mandera etc.
Take responsibility of orphans and make sure that they are in school
Sensitize members of the community on available bursaries and their rights
Work hand in hand with the community by getting to the ground in order to understand and address the situation better
Ensure that the syllabus addresses emerging issues such as HIV/AIDS and drug abuse through the MOE
Strengthen psychology, counseling and philosophy units in teacher training colleges and extend the training to three years
Build more schools within homes like in the slums
Ensure that some land is set aside for schools when coming up with new estates
Depolitisize the management of schools
Prioritize and assist in making sure modern technology is used in teaching
Narrow down the primary school curriculum to acquisition of good basic training in literacy and numeracy instead of combining this with skills training.
Distribute science teachers in marginalized areas
Support and motivate female teachers in marginalized areas
Government officers in the field should enforce MOE policies and ensure that they have action plans
Strengthen and Monitor NFE not as a cheaper form of education but as alternative form of education
Offer alternative basic education nationally
Come up with clear policies and laws to protect the girl especially from forced marriages.
Establish a culture desk at the ministry to handle culturally related issues, which may force girls out of school.
Integrate child rights education in the curriculum just the way they’ve done with HIV/AIDS. That way, girls will not be exploited.
Be committed to EFA goals
Allocate more funds to FPE and monitor its expenditure
Employ more teachers to support FPE
In-service teachers on gender with the support of CSOs
Have a clear policy on two other levels on education, ECD & non-formal education and even mainstream ECDs to be part of the education system.
Support acquisition of facilities in boarding schools for girls.
Support and implement the affirmative action
Civil Society Organizations (NGOs/CSOs) and the Private sector
Poverty: Poverty manifests itself in several ways and has wide ranging effect on people. It is a multidimensional phenomenon that denies people their basic rights to food, shelter, education, clothing etc for their survival and development. It is about exclusion and deprivation and voiceless and powerlessness.
In Kenya about 35% of the population can be considered as poor. The Human Development Report (UNDP, 2001) puts this at 31.1%. Kenya’s poverty index value has steadily risen from 26.1% in 1997 to 34.5% in 2001. Nationally 51% of the total population has poor access (take over one hour to reach the nearest qualified doctor) to health services, high cost and poor quality of services. It is estimated that 56% of Kenya’s population earn less than a dollar a day.
The state of poverty described above therefore calls for the stakeholders from the private sector, CSOs and NGOs to be committed in the fight against poverty in Kenya. The civil society organizations must therefore redouble their efforts to work with the government and other institutions at national and international levels to influence international policies that impinge on food rights, take actions that support the government’s poverty reduction programmes, participate in national forums for policy review formulation and implementation, monitor the micro-economic frameworks (including the PRSPs) to ensure timely implementation and promote the acquisition of life skills for adolescent and teenage girls.
Such organizations should also be involved in implementing service delivery to poor communities in education, health, and income generating activities. The CSOs and NGOs including the private sector should play both advocacy and monitoring role in tracking the state of girl child education in the country.
They should also be involved in community empowerment to address the root causes of poverty through human rights and gender training programmes, access to loans and income generating activities and giving a “voice to the voiceless” in participatory interactive multi-media programmes.
HIV/AIDS and its effects
The consequences of early, unprotected sexual activity among young Kenyans are no longer limited to millions of episodes of STDs and hundreds of thousands of unwanted pregnancies and induced abortions every year among teenage girls of school going age. In addition to these threats to their health, well-being and survival, Kenya’s young girls now have to face up reality of HIV/AIDS in their daily lives. The civil society organizations must therefore enhance advocacy at all levels to build political commitment for priority of reproductive health supplies and services to mobilize the financial resources needed to ensure a consistent, adequate and appropriate supply of reproductive health products, advocate for affordable antiviral drugs as HIV/AIDS is impoverishing individuals and families in a country that is already struggling with poverty.
The CSOs/NGOs should also continue with community sensitization and awareness creation activities for HIV/AIDS prevention and care and strengthen networking to share ideas, experiences and information, and build capacity of communities for home based care of persons infected with HIV/AIDS.
Share learning through networks and coalitions: The Civil Society should network and share experiences in order to avoid duplications within national coalitions to develop communication programmes for girl child education. These alliances are essential for effective implementation of challenges facing girl child education in Kenya. But they also help build consensus among civil society groups on the priority interventions to improve quality, and ensure that different innovations on improving girl child education are build on a shared understanding of past experience.
Strengthen government education policies rather than develop parallel service-delivery approaches. Civil society innovations within the government system could be extended to benefit girl child education in the country.
Lobbying and advocacy with the government and communities for girls’ education with the help of national and international agencies.
6.1.4 Other Recommendations
Use some of their best practices to sensitize the government and influence decisions made in schools
Advise the government on the best possible ways to address issues at the grassroots level
Use integrated approach by focusing on the girl at the same time encompassing the family and society
Directly initiate programs assisting girls in areas of education and training
Influence the government on policy formulation especially the MOE.
Compliment government efforts in provision of girls’ education Monitor the use of resources and management of schools.
Inspect schools to identify girls in problems and intervene.
Mobilize communities to take girls to school and advocate for their education
Stop employing school age girls in factories and send them back to school
Sponsor girls’ in high schools
Sponsor programs on press and electronic media to promote girls’ education
Put up schools as a social responsibility
Use their expertise in various areas to train communities on their needs
Donate towards the education fees of bright and needy girls high school fees.
Provide learning materials
Use their facilities like buses during the weekends to assist schools take pupils for trips as a social responsibility
CSO working in the area of education need to network towards promoting girl friendly schools so that these schools can provide sanctuary and safe, secure environment for the HIV/AIDS affected girls.
Provide employment to girls who have completed schooling and training
Support universities in girls’ and women related projects and research areas
Community
Community sensitization: Mobilization and sensitization of communities to gain family support for the girls’ education. Communities need to be sensitized on the need to educate girl child through public barazas, churches, CSOs etc. The parents and teachers association/school boards must be involved in school activities.
Communities need to be assisted to establish mechanisms to trace and track girls affected by HIV/AIDS who are not in school and then get them enrolled.
Harness available resources within the community to support education projects
Ensure that all parents take their girls to school
Create security measures which will ensure girls safety on their way to and from school
Own all projects implemented by NGOs and CSOs and use them to improve their lives
Understand the role and importance of girls’ education and lobby for parents to take girls to school
Build and maintain physical learning facilities in schools
Reward girls who have excelled in schools by giving sponsorship
Intervene in harmful cultural beliefs and practices which discriminate against the girl child by sensitizing its members against them and demonstrating the need for change
Give free time to the girl by sharing work between boys and girls.
Appreciate and support girls’ education by putting up schools for girls.
Reduce unhealthy relationship in schools by putting up schools exclusively for girls.
Use locally available materials to make teaching and learning materials for schools.
Take responsibility to support ECD.
Monitor money given for FPE implementation and ensure that it is not misused
Donate land for school construction
6.1.6 Schools
Provide a conducive learning environment for girls
Ensure that sanitary facilities for girls are adequate and offer enough privacy
Headteachers should take responsibility to support girls education as a priority issue in their schools
Set up girls’ clubs in schools
All school staff should act as role models to the girls
Encourage girls and motivate them to take up science subjects
Introduce and monitor guidance and counseling program and make sure it is well taught.
Organize teacher trainings on how to handle girls
Educate PTA on matters pertaining to girls’ education
Teach girls life skills emphasizing on self-esteem and self-assertion.
Re-admit girls who have given birth and create a good learning environment for them
Instill discipline in pupils
Access funds to give bursaries to girls.
Create work system where the girl child is paid for work done in order to get money to cater for personal items.
Girls to sensitize boys on girls’ rights.
Disseminate information to boys and other students about their rights as children.
Invite speakers to talk about girls’ rights so that girls are not taken advantage of.
The administration and teachers to change their attitudes towards issues like pregnancies and encourage girls who get pregnant to come back to school after delivery.
6.1.7 Teachers
Act as role models for girls
Create conducive learning environment for girls at the classroom level
Be punished for abusing girls e.g. those who impregnate girls should be prosecuted and their services terminated.
Re-focus on their relationship with girls. Should be friends to the girls first then role models
Teach, guide and instruct girls on good morals
Set aside time to teach remedial lessons to girls who do not get time to do homework.
Understand development of girls so that they can give them more time to use the toilets. For instance girls should be allowed to walk out of class anytime they want to use the washrooms without asking for permission from teachers.
Have medical support in schools. To handle girls ailments.
Provide sanitary facilities sourced from the government, communities and companies. Schools in the rural areas and boarding schools should access freely sanitary facilities.
Should not use girls to run them errands like making tea for them
6.1.8 Parents
Recognize and play their role as parents, teachers, role models and counselors to their children
Create time to be with their children
Build equal amount of confidence in their sons and daughters
Protect their children from rape and ensure their safety
Partner with the government to ensure girls get education
Prioritize girls’ education needs in the family budget
6.1.9 Pupil Recommendations
Both boys and girls need to be sensitized on gender equity and girls made to understand they are not in any way a weaker sex compared to boys.
Encourage counseling for girls in schools
Provide sanitary facilities for girls in schools
Improve school facilities e.g. toilets, classrooms, desks etc.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Colcough Christopher et al, (2002), EFA Goals monitoring Report,
Kenya Alliance For Advancement of Children and Action Aid Kenya, (2001), Children Act,
Ministry of Education, Science and Technology, (2003) Draft Policy Copy on Gender and Education, MOEST
Oxfam GB, (2001), Urban Development Programme A Participatory Urban Appraisal Study of Mashimani, Kambi Muuru, Lindi and Silanga Villages- Kibera Informal Settlements, Final Report,
Republic of Kenya, (2003) Report on The Task Force on Implementation of Free Primary Education, Ministry of Education
Republic of Kenya, (1997), Master Plan on Education and Training 1997 – 2010, Government Publications, Nairobi
Republic of Kenya, (2002) National Development Plan 2002 –2008, Government Publication, Nairobi
The Basic Rights Steering Committee, (December 1998) A Basic Right Chapter, Nairobi
UNESCO, (2001) Monitoring Report on Education For All, UNESCO, France
________(2002) Universal Primary Education Goal For All, UNESCO, France
_________ (2002), EFA Global Monitoring Report, UNESCO, France
UNICEF ESARO, (1999), Report on 1998 AGEI Yearly Technical Report Review meeting UNIEF ESARO,
Wamahiu.S and Kabira. W, (April 1996) Draft report Presented to the Task Force on Review of Laws relating to Women in Kenya, Nairobi,
_________ (1992), The Situation of Female Child in Kenya, Nairobi
________ (2002) (Consultancy report) Strengthening Access To Quality Education For Refugee Girls in The Horn Region and Eastern Africa, Nairobi
APPENDICES
Appendix 1: Organizations addressing Girls’ Education in Kenya
When asked to name any other organizations that are currently involved in girls’ education initiative in Kenya, the following were mentioned by those interviewed in the study. They included: Action Aid, FAWE-Kenya, Oxfam, Elimu Yetu Coalition, Elimu Kwa Wanavijiji Coalition, WEMA, Plan Kenya, Plan International, AIC, FAWE Kenya, KAACR, FIDA, African Network for the Prevention and Protection Against Abuse and Neglect (ANPPCAN) Kenya Chapter, Save the Children Canada/UK, Ford Foundation, Ministry of Education, Ministry of Culture, Gender and Social Services, Womankind, Genesis, MEDs, Mukuru, Maendeleo Ya Wanawake Organization (MYWO), SNV, UNICEF, Pastoralists Education Commission, NGO council, CARE Kenya, Girl Child Network (GCN), ILO, CWSK, LIFA, Kenya Non-Formal Schools Association, National Focal Point, COVAW, Girl Child Project (GCP), Hope for African Child Initiative, British council, Sinaga vocational training, MAP, World Vision, Good neighbors, Catholic Church, Pendekezo Letu, Timau in Meru, Du poto Emaa in Kajiado, Laikipia Indigenous Maasai Group Initiatives (OSILIGI) in Laikipia District, Timau Child and Family Programme in Timau, Tharaka Nithi Dea Deanery in Chuka, Community Education Concern in Nakuru, St. Francis Child and Family Programme in Kisumu, Maasai Girls Education Programme, and Womankind in Garissa.
Appendix 2: Main areas of focus of CSOs in gender and Girls education
Name of OrganizationAreas of Focus in Girls EducationAga Khan Education Foundation ECD programmes at primary schools pre-schools targeting girls
Islamic madarasa classes beyond basic Quranic lessons for girls
Advocacy campaigns for improved girls educationActionAid Kenya AAK established school resource base in which levy saving strategies had been established into community education trust fund (before FPE was introduced)
AAK has trained school committees in management and accountability; encouraging women to participate.
AAK addresses the distance issues affecting girls by establishing feeder/catchment schools located between primary schools and home
Established non-formal education, which captures girls who miss formal schooling.Basic Education Fellowship (BEF) Capacity building and exchange programs
Gender clubs. BEF has been involved in peer support groups for both boys and girls
Childhood problems
Cultural problems e.g. FGM and early marriages
Sensitize and encourage communities to put up boarding facilities at primary level
Removal of girls out of the streets to get then to non-formal schools
HIV/AIDS orphans
Training on gender and child rights
Awareness creation for parents on girl child
Offer training on human resource and financial management
Christian Children’s Fund Building schools and dormitories for girls
Advocacy about some of the practices affecting girls education like FGM
Networking with other CSOs to lobby for correct policies in support of girls educationWomen Educational Researchers of Kenya (WERK) Initiated Girl Child Education Movement (GEM) a participatory movement designed to give children and young girls maximum opportunity to develop and express their own ideas without adult interference
Help girls understand and demand their right to participate in decision making about problems they face during their education.
Help girls develop and use their leadership skills and creative talents
Encourage girls and boys work as partners to find solutions to the problems of girls education
Persuade policy makers and donors to support the right of African girls to good quality education
Encourage debates on issues of girls’ education
Share ideas, experiences and best practices on girls education
Encourage research on girl child education to link advocacy and action
Gender training for younger WERK members to be sensitive to girls education
UNGEI- to help retain girls in schools
In-house seminars, which give WERK members and non-members, chance to present papers done on girls’ education (e.g. female participation in mathematics and science subjects).
African Network for the Prevention and Protection Against Abuse and Neglect (ANPPCAN) Kenya Chapter Girls’ education: create awareness creation on the importance of girls’ education
Legal education/assistance (take cases to court) on behalf of girls who have been neglected by their parents.
Provide child rights awareness.
Promote extra-curricular activities e.g. football events for girls
Support for HIV/AIDS orphansUndugu Society Offers non formal education to destitute and street children including girls
Initiated Undugu schools, which cater for both boys and girls
Informal skills training for graduates
Social work programs which looks after issues affecting girls
Children’s and youth programme in Kitengela targeting mainly girls St. Elizabeth Mukuru Feeding programme for school children
Support to HIV and AIDS positive children
Started FPE before governmentYoung Muslim Association Early Childhood Education (ECD) was the first project to be implemented which also included child care
Developed the Islamic Integrated Education programme in partnership with GoK and UNICEF
Activities boosting primary enrolment among girls
YMA has been carrying out awareness activities on sending girls to school and its advantages
Built primary schools where parents feel comfortable sending both their daughters and sons to school because of the cultural and religious background
Founder member of the Elimu Yetu CoalitionChild Welfare Society of Kenya The organization has a female child programme in Mombassa which is aimed at equipping young girls who drop out of school with skills
Has Rights of Child Programme aimed at ensuring that children’s rights such as girls rights to education are achieved in the communities
Vocational training programme
Institutional care of the orphaned children, foster care and adoption.
Oxfam Gender mainstreaming in development
Street girls education programme – (WEMA center)
Vocational training – Pendekezo Letu in Thika that takes street girls to school and link them with their families
Pastoralist Education – gives support to partners in pastoral areas to improve girls enrolment in schools (e.g. Wajir District)
Promote girls education by supporting schools e.g. Garissa District where Oxfam has put a girls school.
Research on girls education to get best practices/initiatives in girls education
Participatory Urban Appraisal
Financing girls education
Support in-service and training for teachers; post teachers and encourage affirmative action e.g. whereby teachers from the marginalized areas are admitted with lower grades and after training, they are posted to these areas
Policy issues on girls education among the pastoral communities
Encourage and support boarding schools among the nomadic communities
Girl Child Network Gender and girls’ education
Gender violence, counseling and guidance
Sensitize girls on reproductive health and rightsKAACR Girls’ education
Anti FGM and early marriages campaigns
Advocacy with Elimu Yetu at national level focus on policies on girls education
Production of IEC materials on girls education campaigns
Training of PTAs and community members to be more gender responsive
Seminars for both girls and boys on RHs
Media: has radio programmes on girls’ educationPlan Kenya Media: Child Aeffective media project: A video project in schools where children video shot on matters affecting them e.g. drug abuse, early marriages, HIV/AIDS, child labour, FGM, sanitation facilities, childhood diseases
Empowering of children to deal with contemporary social issues e.g. STIs/HIV/AIDS, school drop out, sexual abuse, teenage pregnancy, domestic violence etc
Bursary: Pays school fees for its Plans’ foster children
Career Development: through the Msinga Bora Clubs. Career guidance is imparted to children in colourful Msingi Bora Magazines where children are encouraged to contribute short stories on matters affecting them ACK Church Kajiado Mothers Union
Advocacy – sensitize both the girls and the community in general on the importance of girls’ education.
Support the girls financially to pay fees.Catholic Church Kajiado
Bursary/sponsorship for girls education in secondary school and tertiary levels
Advocacy work on girls and boys education
Rescue of young girls married to old peopleDupoto – Emaa Boarding schools for girls e.g. AIC girls, Ilbilisi, Rombo, DEB, Oloitiktok, Enkijap, Olkiramatyan, Naningoi, Kitengela, Oluguluusi.
Awareness /sensitization on girls’ education with the aim of raising girls’ enrolment in schools.
Educate the community not to participate in harmful cultural practices that hinders girls education e.g. FGM during school days
Continuity – encourage girls to proceed to secondary schools.
Role models – encourage girls and women who have achieved (teachers, nurses, leaders etc) in their own right from the Maasai community to talk to girls to be role models to young girls.
Improve facilities in boarding schools e.g. dormitoriesCHRIST THE KING CATHOLIC CHURCH-KIBERA
Skills acquisition for out of school girls and boys in tailoring, masonry and carpentry
Counseling of pregnant girls on coping mechanisms and to avoid abortion
Advocacy for life through dramaKIBERA SLUM EDUCATION PROGRMME
(KISEP)
Support a few schools in Kibera by providing teaching and learning materials (textbooks, chalk, flipcharts, pens, and manila papers).
Provide furniture (desks, chairs, tables and cupboards) to the needy schools in the slums e.g. Mashimoni Squatters, ACK Primary and St Phillips.
Guidance and counseling for in the schools
HIV/AIDS counseling for girls at the VCT centerFAWE – Kenya Influencing policy formulation with MOE
Advocacy through print and electronic media
Demonstrative interventions i.e. builds centers of excellence
HIV/AIDS intervention programmes
FEMSA schools
Sponsorship for girl child education
Sexual maturation and menstruation projects i.e. demystify maturation and menstruation in girls
Production of IEC materials on girl child
Production of re-usable prototype sanitary pads
Documentation of policies i.e. statistical booklet with MOE
Empowerment of girls through girls clubs and gender clubs in mixed schools
Empower teachers on girl friendly teaching methods and environment
Capacity building for teachers through in-service training
Income generating activities to help support the needy
Provide teaching and learning materials
NTANIRA NA MUGAMBO -THARAKA
Advocacy work to eradicate FGM, early marriages
Curriculum development
Reproductive health (STIs/HIV/AIDS) awarenessMETHODIST CHURCH -THARAKA Create awareness on need to educate the girl child
Plans to provide sponsorship to girls in school. The sponsorship to be funded by Food for the Hungry International will be in the form of uniforms, breakfast, lunch, and supper to the needy children, most of whom will be girlsKWADA Sensitize the community on the importance of girl child education
Used to have bursaries for girls
Encourage parents to construct classes for girls and help to furnish classes with desks and chairsNOSUM WOMEN ORGANIZATION Promote girls enrolment in school
Encourage retention of girls in school
Provide bursaries /funds for girls education
Sensitize Maasai women on the importance of girls’ educationSINAGA CENTRE KASARANI Train girls working as domestic workers on their rights and entrepreneurship skills
Withdrawal and counseling program where girls are withdrawn from working as house maids and trained on basic literacy
Raise awareness against child labour through barazas, mosques and workshops
Training girls on entrepreneurship skills e.g. in tailoring, typing, cookery, and bakery/pastry. Later on they sit for grade 1 test, Pitman exams for typing and KIE cookery exam.
Provide sponsorship to bright girls in formal boarding schools
Attachments for girls to companies where they receive on job training (has over 30 girls attached at the Export Processing Zone and other companies
Loan facilities for girls to buy sewing machines etc.
LINDI USHIRIKA WA USAFI NA MAENDELEO-LUUM
Nursery school for the needy children, which initially had 98 children. Over 60 of these children were girls
Feeding programmes
Advocacy work with Elimu Yetu Coalition on the need for education by participating in Elimu Yetu workshops
Appendix: 3: Existing partnership(s) in Girls Education among organizations
AKEF
Provides funding for CBOs/NGOs though has no formal partnerships, just consultations
Action Aid
KAARCShort term partnership on matters of mutual interest in genderCADECShort term partnership on matters of mutual interest in genderCRADLE Short term partnership on matters of mutual interest in gender
CCF
48 CBOs in 30 districts
Referrals for FAWE
Board of KAACR
Undugu Society
Board of KAACR
St. Elizabeth Mukuru
With MYWO who have established a girls club at the school.
YMA
Establish networks and caucuses with various partners
CWSK
CWSK is a member of GCN for the purpose of sharing experiences on the girls’ child
CWSK’s has programmes in Nyando District – a programme for elimination of child labour
KAACR
Is in partnership with MYWO, Girl Child Network, FAWE especially in ASAL areas, Elimu Yetu (Girl Child Education Initiative) MOE (Gender desk) etc,
Plan Kenya works in partnership with Unicef, GCN, MoE,
FAWE Kenya works in Nyanza, Coast, Nairobi, Central (Thika) Eastern (Mbeere, Kitui) Rift Valley (Kajiado) amongst many others.
BEF
BEF works in partnership with a number of NGOs and CBOs that includes:
Kenya Adult education Association in Nairobi
Dupoto E Maa in Kajiado
The Organization for Survival of Il- Laikipia Indigenous Maasai Group Initiatives (OSILIGI) in Asal Nanyuki
Timau Child and Family Programme in Timau
Tharaka Nithi Dea Deanery in Chuka
Community Education Concern in Nakuru
St. Francis Child and Family Programme in Kisumu
Literacy for All in Kakamega
Womankind in Garissa
FAWE Kenya Chapter in Nairobi
ANNPCAN
The organization works closely with the Girl Child Network (GCN). They address issues on the girl child especially education. ANNPCAN’s other partners are:
Sinaga, which provides basic literacy to girls and vocational training.
World Vision
Good Neighbors
Action Aid,
Catholic Church,
Pendekezo Letu. These organizations all deal with issues of children so they work with them.
Oxfam Partners
Works with marginalized communities that include: pastoralists, agriculturalists focusing on sustainable livelihood and urban slum communities.
Appendix 4: Organizations and locations of operation
Action Aid
Action Aid Kenya operates in poorest districts in Kenya including: Narok, Bomet, Bondo, Kajiado, Kwale Tharaka and Malindi
CCF
Kisumu, Siaya, Busia, Migori, Rongo, Kuria, Suba, Kendu Bay / Rachuonyo, Gucha, Nyando, Turkana, Baringo, Marakwet, Keiyo, Nakuru, Samburu, Marsabit, Isiolo, Laikipia, Meru, Nyeri, Tharaka, Mbeere, Thika, Nairobi, Kajiado, Narok, Makueni, Kitui, Mwingi, Machakos.
UNDUGU
Nairobi, Kajiado, Kisumu
St Elizabeth Mukuru
Nairobi, Kibwezi and Machakos
YMA
Tana River, North Eastern, Kwale, Mombasa.
Nakuru and partner with Nakuru Muslim Association and Nakuru Islamic centre.
In Eldoret: partner with Eldoret Muslim association,
Malindi : partner with Malindi Education development Association,
Mombasa: partner with Mombassa Educational Welfare Association, Islamic teachers Training College in Mikindani and Khalifa Bin Naihal Technical and secondary institute.
CWSK
CWSK has 8 children homes i.e. Nanyuki, Nakuru, Embu, Mombasa, Isiolo, Bungoma and Nairobi.
It has branches in Nyeri, Nyahururu, Kuria, Thika, Murang’a, Malindi, and Kiambu
Mombasa: female child programme
Isiolo: Early marriages
Bungoma: child labour in sugarcane and maize plantations
GCN
Nairobi chapter, which comprises of Thika, Kiambuu and Kajiado and Nairobi
Mt. Kenya chapter, which comprises of Murang’a, Kirinyaga, Embu, Meru and Nyeri
Western Kenya chapter comprising of Kakamega, Kisii and Kisumu
Coast chapter, which comprises of all the districts, Mombasa
KAACR
Works all over the country but has girl child education programmes in Kwale and Kuria districts because of the high rates of early marriages in both districts and FGM in Kuria in particular.
Plan Kenya
Works in a number of districts in Kenya that includes: Nairobi, Kiambu, Thika, Machakos, Kwale, Kilifi, Taita Taveta, Embu, Kisumu amongst many others.
WERK is basically based in Nairobi but WERK members have gone and visited Bondo, Narok, Garisa, Gatwekera slums in particular and Mombassa to advocate for girls rights through the play.
BEF works in Nairobi, ASAL areas of Laikipia and Nanyuki, Timau, Chuka and Tharaka Nithi. Others include Nakuru, Kisumu, Kakamega and Garissa
African Network for the Prevention and Protection Against Abuse and Neglect (ANPPCAN) Kenya Chapter works all over Kenya and has been greatly felt in Nairobi – Korogocho, Soweto in Kayole, Ambira and Sinaga in Siaya.
Oxfam: Works in Nairobi among the urban poor in Kibera, Mathere Valley, Mombasa, Western province, North Eastern province (Wajir and Garisa Districts), Turkana district in Rift Valley province.
Appendix 5: Case Studies
AIC Primary School
Jedida Nkadayo
Class 8
Age 14.
Rescue Case
I am from Engaroni Division of Kajiado District. I have three brothers and four sisters. Two of my siblings, one brother and one sister have gone to school up to primary level. They are sponsored by our uncle who is working in Nairobi.
I Attended Engaroni primary school up to class two then my father said he had no money to educate me. I was circumcised in 1996 and stayed at home the whole year. In 1997 I got married to an old friend of my father. He was my father’s age mate; the old man (my husband) was around 40 years old. He paid dowry in terms of two cows and an unknown amount of money.
My mother told me of the arrangements but I was too young to take any action. I was only 9 years old by then. Then one Saturday morning I went to the chief to report the matter. The chief came to my home (where I was married) then ordered that I should be taken back home. He was promised that I would be returned but my in-laws planned to take me somewhere else to hide from the chief.
When I heard the romours that my in-laws wanted to hide me from the chief, I ran away from my marriage and returned to our home. My father shouted at me. He asked me whether the chief had become my father. The following day my husband came and talked with my father I was then ordered to go back with him, which I obeyed. After spending at my husband’s home for one night I ran back home. Father asked me why I was back home but he did not send me back to my husband’s home, as he feared the chief who had threatened to jail him.
Therefore they allowed me to go back to school but on condition that I would see my husband every weekend. I went to school for one week but refused to see ‘my husband’ during the weekend because it was shameful, other children would laugh at me a married wife in school.
The following week the headmaster called me and asked me to explain to him the problems that I was facing. The chief was also present. They told me to inform my mother that I would go to Kajiado AIC girls of which she made the preparations and I was brought here.
I rarely go home during holidays instead I stay in FAWE hostel constructed in our school compound. As a consequence my father has refused to educate other girls because of my refusal to get married to the man he chose for me. But now I am very fine, FAWE caters for all my needs including, boarding fees school uniforms and exercise books.
Suggestions
Parents should give girls a chance in education.
Men should not see women as objects only to be used.
NGOs should take action they should not just take information for granted.
The Maasais should support girls’ education.
(The girl was very emotional during the interview she was crying as she narrated her story)
Illbissil Primary School
Margaret Paranee.
Class 8
16 years
Run away case
In my family we are 12 children. I am the 11th child. We are 4 boys and 8 girls. Some have been to school while others have not. I joined this school in the year 2002. I was brought by uncle, a brother to my father. I have one parent, mother. My father passed away in 1992. I come from Trans Mara District.
I was in Enoosaini primary school from 6 to 7 then I came here and repeated class 7. From class 1 to 6 I was in Mapashi primary school in Transmara. My brother was told to take care of me after the death of my father. He told me that I must get married. But I said I will not get married until after completing schooling. Then he said if you are not getting married then you will not live in my home. I ran away and went to my uncle’s place who brought me to this school.
I stayed with my uncle for three days then he took me to the DC in Kilgoris, the moment I reached the DC’s office my brother also came there. The DC told him that if the girl doesn’t want to get married, she has a right according to the Kenyan law, so you go back home. When he was told that he told me never to go back to his home.
I was taken to another uncle’s house where I stayed for one month. My first uncle whom I had stayed with for three days brought me to Nairobi to some white sponsors. Ever since they brought me to Nairobi, I rarely go home and when I go, I go to my uncle’s place. From the time I was brought here I was only able to see my mother last holidays.
I am happy that I am in this school. I am learning well and I do not have any problem. In fact my foster parents have adopted me and we live in Karen. Whenever we close school, I go home to Transmara to my uncle’s house for one week where my brothers and sisters visit me. My sponsors have four big children. Two of them are older than me. They treat me very well.
I would like to advice parents not to force children to do things because they are parents but they should let children make individual choices. Also parents should not always expect children to obey them if they are not obeying the children rights.
Moipei Primary School
Susan Kashmir
16 years.
Class 8
Re-entry case
We are about 20 children in my family. My father has four wives and my mother is the last wife. I am the 5th born in my mother’s family of 7 children. We are 3 daughters and 4 sons. They have all been to school. My elder siblings are educated up to form 4, although one of my sisters, the one that I come after only went up to class 8.
I joined this school in 1991 in nursery and then last year when I was in Standard 7 I got pregnant. I took a break in the month of October 2002 to go and give birth. I delivered a baby girl in January this year and then resumed school in May. I am currently in class 8 but I will not sit for examinations because I have missed many lessons.
A young single man impregnated me although I did not want to get married to him, that is why I opted to come back to school. My parents suggested that I come back to school and I accepted. I am happy with my classmates and teachers who treat me with respect. My mother takes care of the baby as I come to school. But I go home to breastfeed during lunchtime and after school. The baby does not affect my schooling at all. At home I have time to do my homework.
I am interested in learning even up to secondary level and beyond but my parents cannot afford school fees for higher learning that is why one of sisters is at home. She helps mother to take care of the baby.
Suggestions
If girls give birth while in school they should not drop out but come back.
Girls to try to avoid sexual contacts with men
They should not accept to be cheated by men
FPE Case
I was born in August 1986 in Uganda. My parents died when I was two months old. We are four in the family. I am the last-born. After my parents’ death, I went to live with my auntie while my two sisters and one brother went to live with my paternal grandmother.
My auntie enrolled me in a school in Uganda. I can’t remember how old I was then. Two of my sisters were also enrolled in school but dropped out in class five and six. My brother dropped out in class four.
I continued with school until class 3 when another auntie brought me to live with her in Nairobi. By then, I could not communicate in Kiswahili or English. I stayed at home for one year after which she enrolled me in Moyo Academy, a primary school in Dandora. I joined standard three in 1996. She had four children who all went to boarding schools and I was therefore the only one at home. We later moved to Kibera and I joined Kabiru Primary School till class six when I dropped out because of lack of fees.
My auntie got me a job as a maid. I was earning Kshs. 500per month. I used to save some of the money and spend some on personal needs. From my savings, I sent some to my sisters in Uganda.
My work included cooking, washing, ironing and preparing children to go to school. My employer was good to me but I never enjoyed preparing her three children to go to school while I stayed behind to work.
In January this year, I heard on the T.V that primary education was free. I informed my employer that I wanted to go back to school and requested her to seek admission for me. She told me to look for a school myself. I informed my auntie of my decision and started looking for a school. I went to Toy, Ayany, Kibera, Joseph Kagethe and Mbagathi primary schools and was told they were all full. Finally I came to Shadrack Kimalel. I talked to the headmistress who referred me back to Joseph Kagethe Primary School but also told me to go back to her school if I missed admission. I was not successful and so I came back to Shadrack Kimalel where I was admitted in standard seven.
With my savings, I bought uniform, shoes, socks and a bag. The pupils in my class were welcoming though they said that I would find my studies difficult after being out of school.
I have since then settled though I find GHC, Science and English difficult. At the end of last term, I was position 43 out 53. I am the only new pupil in my class. I want to work hard and become a nurse. The headmistress has promised to help me pay school fees if I pass KCPE. I gave my class teacher Kshs. 1500 to keep for me and I have the same amount at home in my bag. I keep this money aside so that I can pay for anything the teachers may ask for.
On Saturday, I work at a saloon in Milimani. With the money I earn, I am able to buy lunch in school
Justine Nekesa
16 years old,
Standard 7
Shadrack Kimalel Primary
Out Of School Case Study
I was born in 1989 and my mother is a single mother. I was enrolled in class 1in 1995 in Majengo primary school, a private school.
My mother had a lot of problems like raising money for food and rent. We were occasionally locked out by the landlord for not paying rent on time.
We moved to Mukuru, which we thought was much cheaper. Mother managed to pay rent for some time. Initially, I found it difficult to cope but late adjusted to the living conditions in Mukuru.
When I was in class three, my mother got a baby and life became difficult. I began going without lunch to school. During this time, our neighbour called Baba Amos could bring some food for us and give my mother some money. I came to learn later that he was my sister’s father.
My mother tried doing some business. She could travel upcountry to buy cereals for sale. On e day in 1999, I returned home to learn that my mother had died in a road accident.
There was no money to enable us go for the funeral. I have never believed she died because I have never seen her grave. By the time she died, we were living with Baba Amos. After some time, schooling became difficult for me because of lack of fees and books. I dropped out of school when Baba Amos said he could not afford the fees.
I knew of children who were sponsored by CCF and some churches. I wanted to go seek for sponsorship but Baba Amos said that the sponsorships were funded by the devil.
We still live with baba Amos in one room. He is not married. I work in order to provide for my sister. I wash clothes in peoples’ homes. I also help baby Amos sell ‘busaa’.
Recently, I got a sponsor for my sister. When FPE was introduced, I wanted to go back to school but baba Amos became very harsh. I don’t think he has ever been to school though he knows how to count money.
I have never known any relatives. My mother never introduced me to any. In my life in school, I was always position one despite the difficulties I was going through.
Lati Iquilo
Christ the King Primary School.
Standard 2.
Twelve years old
I live with my father, a sister and a brother. My mother left us . I am the eldest. I went to nursery but skipped class one as there was no vacancy./ I enrolled for school late because I used to live with my mother who could not afford to take me to school. She brought me to my father in Kibera. A Catholic sister in charge of sponsorships identified my siblings and me and enrolled us in Christ the king. I am a sponsored pupil. Sister bought for us uniform. She provides us with books and pencils. My father doesn’t have a stable job. He is a tailor but he lost his job. Sister provides food for us. She brings us sugar, oil, porridge flour, rice, cabbage and paraffin. When my father has money, he buys us food. My mother lives in Waithaka. She got another baby. She doesn’t come to visit us. I would like my father to get a job. I want to learn and become a teacher.
Mari Manti primary school
Tharaka District
Jacqueline Fatuma
Age 11
Std one
New entrant to FPE
She first attended school at Kayole in Nairobi and dropped at Std one at the age of seven. She dropped out because of separation of her parents. At the age of 8, her father took her to Mari Manti to stay with her grandmother. Jacqueline could not continue with education because her grandmother had no money and her father could only visit once year.
At some point, her father gave some money to her grandmother so that she could continue with school. However, the grandmother got sick and spent all the money in the hospital. On hearing that the government shall provide FPE, the father gave some money for uniform to Jacqueline’s grandmother so that she could be enrolled in Std 1. Since she joined Std 1 this year, Jacqueline fees very comfortable and likes reading. She associates well with other children and likes playing. The only shortcoming is that her grandmother is not able to provide adequate food due to poverty. In spite of this, Jacqueline says that were it not have been for FPE, she could still be at home due to lack of fees yet she has always wished to be in school.